In my oppinion you are wrong. But that's fine, as you think I am wrong too. I've grown great genetics in crappy growing environments and gotten good results, I've also grown shitty genetics in great environments and gotten shitty results. I agree with what some of what you are saying, as environmental conditions do play a huge role in how a crop turns out, but if the quality genetics aren't there it doesn't matter how good of a environment you have provided it's not going to improve the quality. Growers with your mindset think that if they have everything in check that their production will be top notch because it was in a perfect environment regardless of genetics or anything like that, and that's just not the case. I was also reffering to the OP's situation, and not as a whole. He has decent lights (not cfl's like you refer to), he has his nutrient makeup (super soil), and the rest of the environment seems in check. And you still don't think it has everything to do with genetics or the phenotype? You're nuts!
W.C.C.