Shortly after Rep. Katie Hill announced her resignation from Congress on Sunday night, the RedState reporter who published damaging allegations involving the Democratic rising star, along with a nude photo, was urging support for Republican candidates to win the seat.
“If you want to help us flip @KatieHill4CA's former #CA25 seat BACK to RED, please learn more about @MikeGarcia2020 and contribute to his campaign at
http://ElectMikeGarcia.com!”
tweeted Jennifer Van Laar, a deputy managing editor at RedState.
Later, Van Laar
suggested that she’d back former Congressman Steve Knight if he decided to run for the seat he lost to Hill in 2018. “He has integrity, cares about the individual, and is a policy wonk,” wrote Van Laar, who noted working for Knight’s 2014 campaign. “I'd be #TeamKnight again in a heartbeat.”
Van Laar’s views, like RedState’s leanings, are no secret: She’s worked in Republican politics and the site is conservative, as is its owner, Salem Media Group. But Van Laar’s shift from reporting on Hill, and publishing what some have deemed
“revenge porn,” to promoting Republicans for Hill’s old job is a blurring of roles that would be unacceptable in mainstream newsrooms.
In the days leading up to the 2018 election, Van Laar
wrote an op-ed on why she supported Knight in his race against Hill, and in July, she
praised a Republican who at the time was planning to run against Hill in 2020. “Hanging out with our future Congresswoman Suzette Valladares today!” she
wrote, along with hashtags such as “#runsuzetterun” and #savecalifornia.”
Van Laar did not respond to a Twitter direct message request to discuss her coverage. Multiple representatives from Townhall Media, which oversees RedState, did not respond to phone and email requests.
Hill’s swift political downfall highlights the way in which allegations and images that might not meet the bar for publication in traditional newsrooms, the one-time media gatekeepers, can find a wide audience online and spark a scandal covered by mainstream reporters.
Hill, who is bisexual, admitted last week to having an “inappropriate” relationship with a female campaign staffer, but has denied having a sexual relationship with legislative director Graham Kelly, the latter of which would violate House ethics rules and became the subject of an investigation.
Hill’s estranged husband, Kenny Heslep, accused her having a relationship with Kelly, as RedState’s Miranda Morales
wrote on Oct 10. Just over a week later, Van Laar
reported that Hill had been in a long-term “throuple” relationship with her husband and the female campaign staffer, in a piece which included a photo of a naked Hill brushing the hair of a woman whose face is intentionally blurred.
The photo, which spread online and on social media, dramatically increased pressure on Hill, who said she decided to resign so that “the good people who supported me will no longer be subjected to the pain inflicted by my abusive husband and the brutality of hateful political operatives who seem to happily provide a platform to a monster who is driving a smear campaign built around cyber exploitation.”
While many Democrats, including Speaker Nancy Pelosi, endorsed her decision to leave Congress on the grounds of having had a relationship with a campaign staffer, some others depicted her as a victim of cyber-bullying by RedState and her estranged husband.
Brianna Wu, a video game developer who lost a bid for Congress in 2018 and is running again in 2020,
tweeted Monday that conservative outlets that published private photos of Hill “enabled her ex-husband's abuse.”
“Hill was exploited by her abusive ex-husband who used nude photos of her to smear her,” Wu added. “No one would argue that it's proper to have a consensual relationship w/ a subordinate. That doesn't change the fact that Hill is a victim of revenge porn.”