Holy shit dude, get out of binary mode. When it comes to consuming gas/oil as part of daily use, they're obviously better. And when it comes to manufacturing the vehicle itself, they are almost certainly worse. It's not one or the other, it's both.
Full throttle is from the Times, go complain to them about their "desperation". The article isn't binary either, because the Times aren't idiots. They're able to see the negative aspects *as well as* the positive aspects. Around here, people refuse to acknowledge any of the negative aspects, and yet, even though I've talked about both, it's all you can see.
The only thing that's irritating is talking to people that can't read. This is just standard idiot stuff where any discussion of something negative about something you like, feels overwhelming and it's all you can see. I'm not a tesla hater, or even a musk hater, but I think it's what people assume when something negative is mentioned. If you can't acknowledge something good about something you don't like, or something bad about something you do like, you've failed logic 101, or got an A in idiot 101, however you want to look at it.
I love electric stuff and have probably been a lot more involved with it for a much longer time than any of you. I flew electric airplanes for a decade and manufactured them for a few years. I was in there at the transition from ni-mh to lipo back in the etec1200 days, the first lipo's to come to the consumer market, soldering up my own packs for a long time until they became commonplace. I have probably a hundred tesla cells sitting around here in my office. I have three battery backup boxes I custom built with solar charge controllers and solar panels to charge them when the power goes out. I worked as an electronics tech for a handful of years. I can't express how down with solar/EV I am, but because I'm not a dishonest sack of shit, I'll be first in line to talk about the negative aspects.