Is she going to survive?

D

drgonzo2476

Member
So I had this issue with getting the membrane off of this seedling, finally got it off a couple of days ago. Now the cotelydon leaves are yellow and I'm a bit worried. Anyone dealt with this before? And before all of the armchair critics come out about the soil, keep your comments to yourself please. I have 3 other seedlings that are doing just fine in the same medium.
 

Attachments

Johiem

Johiem

Well-Known Member
You've got some green growth going. I wouldn't give up on her just yet. As you said she was having problems opening her cotyledon which will inhibit her photosynthesis causing the yellowing. Light breeze and let her roll.
 
crimsonecho

crimsonecho

Well-Known Member
drgonzo2476 said:
Well in my experience with these forums and online in general people tend to want to just be critical instead of helpful. Wanted to nip that in the bud so to speak. So suck it. How's that for a great attitude?
Click to expand...
yeah not good for a great attitude again anyway have fun with your seedling maybe after you get a couple of grows under your belt you can keep a seedling healthy too who knows world is full of wonders and your medium sucks so suck on that :D
 
D

drgonzo2476

Member
I'm on my third grow, but I have already brought 7 plants from seed to harvest. And I currently have 3 in flower that I started from seed. That's 10 for 10. With that same soil. I use what I have available to me at the time and still get the results I want. So keep your pretentious high and mighty bullshit to yourself.
 
D

drgonzo2476

Member
I find my people skills are pretty solid, it's people that usually suck. I have no issue with anyone offering an opinion, but don't be shocked when I come back with opinions of my own. Perhaps I just enjoy taking the piss out of pretentious, "enlightened" stoners. I'll have forgotten this entire exchange by the time I go to bed. So lighten up broooo
 
VincenzioVonHook

VincenzioVonHook

Well-Known Member
drgonzo2476 said:
I find my people skills are pretty solid, it's people that usually suck. I have no issue with anyone offering an opinion, but don't be shocked when I come back with opinions of my own. Perhaps I just enjoy taking the piss out of pretentious, "enlightened" stoners. I'll have forgotten this entire exchange by the time I go to bed. So lighten up broooo
Click to expand...
"ItS nOt mE iTs EvErYoNe ElSe"

Keep telling yourself that mate.
 
D

drgonzo2476

Member
Johiem said:
You've got some green growth going. I wouldn't give up on her just yet. As you said she was having problems opening her cotyledon which will inhibit her photosynthesis causing the yellowing. Light breeze and let her roll.
Click to expand...
Thank you for the only constructive advice I received from this post. I appreciate it.
 
D

drgonzo2476

Member
Well this has been about a constructive as I thought it would be from this forum. Guys. I understand that this is not a good medium for seedlings. I'm not ignorant. However I use what I have available to me at the time sometimes, for various reasons. Like I said I have 3 other seedlings doing just fine and have brought 7 other plants from seed to harvest using the same medium for seedlings. Do I want to use something better in the future? Yes, of course I do. But this is what I'm working with right now so let's focus on what I'm actually asking.
 
S

Skillcraft

Well-Known Member
drgonzo2476 said:
Well this has been about a constructive as I thought it would be from this forum. Guys. I understand that this is not a good medium for seedlings. I'm not ignorant. However I use what I have available to me at the time sometimes, for various reasons. Like I said I have 3 other seedlings doing just fine and have brought 7 other plants from seed to harvest using the same medium for seedlings. Do I want to use something better in the future? Yes, of course I do. But this is what I'm working with right now so let's focus on what I'm actually asking.
Click to expand...
We all understand that you work with what you have and can afford. We all started out that way. But when asking for help it is usually a good practice to not be so confrontational from the jump. At least wait until someone says something offensive before you jump to conclusions. I wish you luck with your plant and hope you get her figured out.
 
D

drgonzo2476

Member
Frankly I don't think everyone understands but whatever. I don't think I came in "so confrontational" by merely mentioning arm chair critics and I said please when speaking about the soil comments. My experience in these forums is a bunch of people just criticizing, not constructively criticizing. Pointing out your faults without offering anything constructive whatsoever. This whole post is kinda proof of it. But I'm confrontational. You guys probably thought Will Smith was justified in slapping Chris Rock too.
 
Hiphophippo

Hiphophippo

Well-Known Member
Everybody probably agrees with the one post of constructive info you got. I’ve always found that you have to be able to take it to deal it. If your asking for help be prepared to catch some slack it’s the nature of the beast but if you throw shade at the slack givers in your initial request for help understand it’ll come ten fold. Just some advice from an old asshole.
 
A

Astral22

Well-Known Member
Just treat it like the other seedlings, it will be lagging behind but it might survive.
Maybe start germinating another seed as a backup if you want to keep all your seedlings at a similar stage. Worst case scenario you would lose just 1 seed, or grow another extra plant :D
 
VincenzioVonHook

VincenzioVonHook

Well-Known Member
drgonzo2476 said:
Well this has been about a constructive as I thought it would be from this forum. Guys. I understand that this is not a good medium for seedlings. I'm not ignorant. However I use what I have available to me at the time sometimes, for various reasons. Like I said I have 3 other seedlings doing just fine and have brought 7 other plants from seed to harvest using the same medium for seedlings. Do I want to use something better in the future? Yes, of course I do. But this is what I'm working with right now so let's focus on what I'm actually asking.
Click to expand...
We don't have an issue with your medium, it seems you do internally. We have an issue with your immediate hostility.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top