Forums Say Soil is Best, Commercial Growing Pro's telling me Coco is best.

PopAndSonGrows

Well-Known Member
me too
Except with cali CARB restrictions - fuck them.
I'm not a fan of "fart-can" exhausts, but I should be allowed to put something more free-flowing. Even if I pass particulate smog test, a modified system will fail visual. TOTAL BULLSHIT, but, at the end of the day, I guess I do appreciate the cleaner air. . ..
 

Budzbuddha

Well-Known Member
Wish I could spiel on cali’s draconian “ air bullshit “ but …. In keeping the subject at hand - coco or 100% perlite grows.
Soil is lazy but still play with blends. Plants in coco or hempy tend to be bigger / more robust. Simpler to feed - GH Maxibloom / minor kelp amendments / done.

No screening bags of medium for pebbles and other shit.
 

Star Dog

Well-Known Member
Haa anyone mentioned capillary matting?

It's the simplest auto feed you can imagine and costs peanut to make.

It works well in any size I've used 120x120mtr capillary trays with good results and very little maintenance.
 

Grow Monster

Well-Known Member
If you are only feeding once or twice a week, you aren't practicing traditional hydroponics.
Thats why I said traditional cus I don't follow those practices now but then the octopots were hydroponics. Its a self watering pot. U just fill when empty. The nutes are in the water which could last days. My point was I didn't have to mix nutes daily with those pots which for me was easier.
 

PadawanWarrior

Well-Known Member
Haa anyone mentioned capillary matting?

It's the simplest auto feed you can imagine and costs peanut to make.

It works well in any size I've used 120x120mtr capillary trays with good results and very little maintenance.
Can those overflow if something sticks?
 

Moabfighter

Well-Known Member
It’s hard to dial in coco without a RO skid and dosatrons. Coco is fantastic for small sized pots for quite large plants. Not to say the average homegrower can’t grow fantastic in coco, but you really gotta have it dialed in or you’ll quickly see problems.

as someone else said, soil is more forgiving for the lazy man or a semi off feed. If you fuck up feeding in coco, you’ll quickly see it….
 

xtsho

Well-Known Member
Haa anyone mentioned capillary matting?

It's the simplest auto feed you can imagine and costs peanut to make.

It works well in any size I've used 120x120mtr capillary trays with good results and very little maintenance.
I have numerous times in other threads. Nobody seems to be very interested. I'm not using it myself but it's been on my todo list for a few years. How is it working out?

 

Hollatchaboy

Well-Known Member
It’s hard to dial in coco without a RO skid and dosatrons. Coco is fantastic for small sized pots for quite large plants. Not to say the average homegrower can’t grow fantastic in coco, but you really gotta have it dialed in or you’ll quickly see problems.







as someone else said, soil is more forgiving for the lazy man or a semi off feed. If you fuck up feeding in coco, you’ll quickly see it….
this is my first time growing in coco. I hand water once a day to ~20% runoff. I feel like they look pretty good, no?



 

Attachments

Star Dog

Well-Known Member
I have numerous times in other threads. Nobody seems to be very interested. I'm not using it myself but it's been on my todo list for a few years. How is it working out?

The only downside to it I've found is not being able to move the plants, after I've cut the the places in the lid/plastic the plants root to the spot.

That aside it's great there's only a reservoir to keep topped up and it's all done for you, I'll be swapping back to it in future.
 

Star Dog

Well-Known Member
Years back i used this botch for my mother's and it worked great.
_20221220_011608.JPG
_20221220_011637.JPG
a pot of perlite and let it do its thing.

Again I've used the same principle with 120x120 trays with good results and minimal effort.
 

Crazy4coco

Member
Hello! So I've been tirelessly reading online for some time to discover if it's worth jumping to coco-perlite from soil, with liquid nutrients.

Every post I see practically says soil tastes better and yields only slightly less.

However I've spoken to a few commercial growers, I'm talking legal growers with factories and they all swear by their coco methods giving just as good weed as soil if not better.

Are the commercial growers simply chasing the yield/speed and the quality could be better in the soil? Or is it legit that the coco method can outperform soil with the best professional level of care? What say you!?:wall:
I’m a coco lover , I think drain to waste is easiest for a new grower trying hydro . Hempy too ! Water/feed daily with a good runoff . Learn how to take ph readings and adjust to 5.8 and your golden . Just increase your nutes gradually . That’s what I find great about hydro / coco . You can always flush and hit the reset button . I find coco and DWC is fast and premium smoke . But for personal what we use to call lawyer bud outdoor organic hands down .
 
Top