25 gallon tub vs five 5 gallon pots

Delps8

Well-Known Member
I grow in a res that holds 28 gallons of nutes. I tried growing three, then two, and settled on one plant at a time. That works OK but I can't quite fill out the tent with one plant so I'm changing tactics and growing two now.

Even with two plants, it can be a handful. I stopped growing autos because they can grow completely out of control.

One nice to work with photo.
IMG_0174.jpeg

Two autos, one was a berserker. There is a plant hiding on the left side of the tent.
IMG_7406.jpeg

Two autos, different grow. Not as unruly as the one above but still a PITA.
IMG_9114.jpeg
 

Delps8

Well-Known Member
Your twoser definitely looks the happiest.
I've never seen a root system of a hydroponic B4 but if you start with 28 gallons, how much volume do you think the roots end up using?
The root ball looks pretty big but maybe a gallon or so? I'm pretty sure that the root ball below would fit inside a 1 gallon pitcher.
1729480863291.jpeg
 

Star Dog

Well-Known Member
I've grown 2 plants in a pot a number of times and never had any problems whatsoever.

I've 2 and 1 right next door with little difference in yeild per plant, actually i could argue some done better 2 in a pot.
20240830_195856.jpg
 

Delps8

Well-Known Member
I've grown 2 plants in a pot a number of times and never had any problems whatsoever.

I've 2 and 1 right next door with little difference in yeild per plant, actually i could argue some done better 2 in a pot.
One issue with multiple plants in a single res is that the roots intertwine and that can be an issue if one plant has to be harvested early. If that does happen, the way to deal with it is harvest that plant but leave enough foliage on it so that they plant is still alive. That allows the roots to stay alive, as well.

Re. yield - I think it's fair to say that, unless you come up with an extreme example, the "ideal" number of plants is the number of plants that it takes to fill the entire grow space. For the last few grows, I've only grown one plant but haven't filled out the grow space. One reason is that I use a veg light, which results in shorted plants but, even after topping and LST'ing as best I could, the plant was 30" x 24" (front to back) so I had 18" "unused". Sure, I could have used the flower light, instead of the veg light, and maybe made it a little wider but that would have also made the front to back measurement too big to fit in the tent. For my current grow, I'm going with two plants in a 2' x 4' and that should "fill the entire grow space".

At the other end of the plant count argument is the argument that Mr Growit makes in his video "Why I grow small plants". He presents some really solid arguments, the best being that growing, say, 4 plants in s 2' x 4' means that you're able to fill the grow space but, because the plants are smaller, you flip them younger, and, as a result, your grows don't take as long as a "regular" grow. I can't fault his logic there. That also has the advantage of allowing a grower to grow different strains, so, overall, I think he's on to something.

"better 2 in a pot" - no argument from me!
 
Top