I never had any luck with soil but It's because I never really put any effort into growing back then and when I finally did put forth effort I had jumped immediately into hydroponics (I ran DWC a few years ago, loved it) the growth rate is crazy nice and if you can keep everything dialed in (even remotely well) you're usually going to get some nice growth from my limited experience. DWC I found was a little bit of a pain in the ass with SCOG because lifting the bucket lid sometimes was a bit annoying to add nutes and flushing, well that was damn near impossible with a SCROG if you needed to remove the bucket or anything... I had modular screens attached to each bucket which made it work for me.
Yeah, I can't say much about soil as I have no real experience with it... I harvested from soil once but it was a first grow and was not done correctly at all... hell I had a Mercury Vapor outdoor security light thinking since it was big and bright it would work well... it worked, but not that well. LOL
You wouldn't need to use all these nutes though, you could get by on just the Lucas formula (micro & bloom, both inexpensive $25-30'ish a gallon) but you'd want supplements and additives ideally of course... I think a CalMag supplement would likely be a necessity but those are pretty reasonable in price too. A lot of the stuff I have is 'extras' anyway just for a little more boost but not needed I'm sure.