More Union Junkets
• Teamsters San Francisco spent more than $57,300 in tax-free union member dues for a "golf fundraiser" in Rancho Canada Golf Club in 2011, government documents show.
• In 2011, UAW Local 2110 of New York City rang up a more than $8,900 tab at the New York Museum of Modern Art for unspecified expenses.
• The UAW Local 862 of Louisville, Ky., spent more than $9,700 at a Six Flags Kentucky Kingdom, a Louisville theme park.
The New York State Public Employees Conference
The New York State Public Employees Conference is New York State's largest public sector union organization, representing thousands of policemen, firemen and transit workers, among others. It routinely attacks state officials as well as New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg for not stopping government waste. However:
• It held its annual conference last year over six days at the luxury Caribe Hotel in San Juan, Puerto Rico, according to the
New York Post, costing union members an undisclosed sum. Rooms cost more than $200 a night. About 300 bosses flew from New York to attend, the
Post says.
"There goes our union dues!" fumed a furious Local 3 electrician, the
Post reported. "They paid for that junket with union dues." Another electrician member said: "I've worked for 10 months in the last two years. I'm getting laid off at the end of the year," adding, "I have no use for the union. All I see is waste, corruption and hypocrisy."
The
Post also quoted an Upper West Side fireman: "We're all based here in New York anyway, so why would they spend all that money on going someplace else? They could have just had it here."
"We're not making any comments," said two labor bosses the
Post reported were lounging by the Caribe pool, one shirtless, the other wearing a New York Fire Dept. shirt.
The
Post reported "a tanned Steve Melish, 'a bigwig in the union that represents municipal painters,' said the convention was 'absolutely serious business.'"
"If it was all sun and fun, I wouldn't be here," said Melish. "There is a lot of business that goes on down here."
When his tan was noted by a reporter, Melish quipped, "You're in Puerto Rico. You can't be in your room all day."
Unions also would get failing grades if they were held to the same standards as other nonprofits.
Unions get automatic dues sent to them by members, but union officials typically spend more than half of their union funds on overhead for things like officials' pay.
That's the finding from a 2008 study based on federal data by Paul Kersey, a director at the Illinois Policy Institute and former director of labor policy at the
Mackinac Center for Public Policy from September 2007 to May 2012. He studied documents filed by six unions in Michigan, the Teamsters, the UAW, Service Employees International, AFSCME, the National Education Association/Michigan Education Association, and United Brotherhood of Carpenters and Joiners of America.
Kersey found that, on average, unions spent less than half of their funds on representing members for things like better pay at work.
"The picture that emerges" from federal data "is one of bloated, directionless union organizations with excessive overhead and administrative costs," Kersey said. Overhead costs for unions "are unusually high," he said.