It's a contradiction, for sure. Our health care system sucks in so many ways. I voted for Bernie in 2016 on this issue. And yet, in 2018 and heading into the 2020 election season, this poll caught my attention:
Majorities of Americans rate the coverage (69%) and quality (80%) of the healthcare they personally receive as "excellent" or "good," but Americans are much less positive about healthcare in the U.S. in general.
news.gallup.com
Most Americans Still Rate Their Healthcare Quite Positively
WASHINGTON, D.C. -- As the incoming Congress prepares to debate further changes to the U.S. healthcare system, solid majorities of Americans rate the coverage (69%) and quality (80%) of the healthcare they personally receive as "excellent" or "good." By contrast, Americans are much less positive about healthcare in the U.S. in general, with a bare majority rating the quality of U.S. healthcare positively (55%) and about a third giving positive reviews to U.S. healthcare coverage (34%).
Other polls show how confused most people in the US are regarding opinions and beliefs about single payer health care coverage.
Suffice it to say that we are at a tipping point and leaning toward some form of universal healthcare coverage but the issue is far from settled. Don't forget that in 2020 then President Trump loomed large. 30% hardcore support for him, 30% hardcore opposition to him and 40% swing voters. Sentiment toward Trump more or less mirrored sentiment toward government provided health care coverage. Then Bernie showed up like a huge wrecking ball for Democratic Party's chances of replacing him with a vaguely worded, unfunded mandate that bans single payer coverage without any details of what would replace it, how much it would cost and who would pay for it. It was an irresponsible act by Bernie. It was just a political act with no substance behind it. Swing voters were not going to support it. As it was, Bernie's bill almost cost us four more years of Trump and probably our democracy with it.
So, separate out the lunacy of our current system from the politics of Bernie's bill and his run at the nomination in 2020. Our system has to change to cover everybody. "Bernie and his Medicare for all" bill were a threat to our democracy in 2020. Both are true.