speedwell68
Well-Known Member
I'm not narrow minded in the slightest. I love little experiments like this. I think it has merit. My limited understanding that sugars help to feed the microbes in the soil, which in turn aid the plant. But the OP has just done it and proclaimed it to be a scientific fact and presented some fairly mediocre plants as proof, that isn't how science works. As I said before all he has proven is that adding sugar doesn't kill them.Don't worry about the "so called" experts on here mate. There are dicks everywhere on this site. Don't bother arguing. They are too narrow minded and subjective to even listen.
I have done shit like this before. Back in the day there was a readers letter to the High Times, that stated as a fact, that watering with carbonated spring water weekly increased yield. So I got two clones side by side and tried it. No difference at all. One thing I did learn is that fungus gnats hate carbonated spring water. The guy's theory was that the spring water would be a good source of carbon dioxide and it contained trace elements like zinc, calcium, magnesium and so on. His theory had merit, but in practice it was flawed, because a good fertiliser should have all of that stuff anyway and the concentration of CO2 was so low it made no difference. But I can safely say that fungus gnats hate it, a couple of decades later I would still reach for the carbonated water if I got fungus gnats, it really drives the little bastards out of the soil.
The OP brought all this shit on himself. If he had posed his post as a question rather than a statement of fact he would have got a whole different response. The other day I questioned something that was a deviation from the norm and the resulting thread was a positive discussion. Yesterday, I was a bit presumptuous and gave advice that wasn't that great and I was called out on it, fair enough IMHO.
If you want to play on forums like these you have to get some thicker skin. If you play the game, you will reap what you sow. If you are a dick and post ill thought out crap, you will also reap what you sow. If you think this is bad you should have been on Usenet in the mid 90s to early 2000s.