The 'Official' Rollitup 'Like' List

MichiganMedGrower

MichiganMedGrower

Well-Known Member
Fogdog said:
"OK, so your answer is, "I am Jewish because I was raised in the culture and identify with that culture even though I am not observant" Gotcha

I'm still not sure what you are saying about ancestry as an identifying feature. Using Buck as an example, he married a Jewish woman and -- at least at RIU -- says he now identifies himself as a Jew. I don't know what he did in terms of temple classes or learning a secret handshake or whatever. Can a person who is not born of Jewish ancestry ever call himself Jewish? Does he have to be more observant than you are?
Click to expand...

2 things

I never said culture you did. I said heritage.

And why do you defend cultures all day long and then attack me for one you are assigning me?
 
MichiganMedGrower

MichiganMedGrower

Well-Known Member
Thundercat said:
I think converting to something and then choosing to be non-observant is kinda lame.

If you wanna be non observant Jewish I feel it should be a heritage thing.

If your gonna bother to choose to convert and call yourself Jewish then I think you should own it, or your just a poser not really Jewish.....

I also don't think marrying a Jewish women inherently makes you Jewish. It seem like it either needs to be heritage or a religious/cultural choice. IMHO
Click to expand...

Thank you. That is what i am saying too.
 
Fogdog

Fogdog

Well-Known Member
MichiganMedGrower said:
2 things

I never said culture you did. I said heritage.

And why do you defend cultures all day long and then attack me for one you are assigning me?
Click to expand...
dude,

At which point in this have I attacked you? Is that what you seek? I'd rather we talk and not do the idiots dance.

Ok, so heritage not culture..

That still doesn't answer my question to you. I'm still not sure what you are saying about heritage as an identifying feature. Using Buck as an example, he married a Jewish woman and -- at least at RIU -- says he now identifies himself as a Jew. I don't know what he did in terms of temple classes or learning a secret handshake or whatever. Can a person who is not born of Jewish ancestry ever call himself Jewish? Does he have to be more observant than you are?
 
MichiganMedGrower

MichiganMedGrower

Well-Known Member
Fogdog said:
dude,

At which point in this have I attacked you? Is that what you seek? I'd rather we talk and not do the idiots dance.

Ok, so heritage not culture..

That still doesn't answer my question to you. I'm still not sure what you are saying about heritage as an identifying feature. Using Buck as an example, he married a Jewish woman and -- at least at RIU -- says he now identifies himself as a Jew. I don't know what he did in terms of temple classes or learning a secret handshake or whatever. Can a person who is not born of Jewish ancestry ever call himself Jewish? Does he have to be more observant than you are?
Click to expand...

Of course he can call himself jewish. If he practices the religion. He just cant share in the heritage. Just the culture.
 
NWO4LIFE

NWO4LIFE

Active Member

This picture appears to be a scene from the hit television show "Family Guy". I did not make the picture this is a satirical post that the image fits in with the recent tribal warfare between buck and MMG. I do not mean for this to be anti semetic or the posting of a nazi. I apologize if you feel it is.
 
Rob Roy

Rob Roy

Well-Known Member
londonfog said:
@Rob Roy hates math and even more he hates black men that know math. He thinks it is impossible. He also wants restaurant owners to have the right to kick blacks out their public place of business. He as well suggested that a 12 year old can consent to sex with an adult...because how do we know that 12 year old is not more mature than others:shock:
Rob is pretty fucked up
Click to expand...

 
B

bundee1

Well-Known Member
This thread was a shitshow to begin with. It was literally a popularity contest.
Rob Roy said:
Isn't all that action rough on your knees?
Click to expand...
Did you pass on a free education on principle? Oh no you just half assed it like most entitled Americans.

Also weak, unimaginative response.
 
Rob Roy

Rob Roy

Well-Known Member
bundee1 said:
This thread was a shitshow to begin with. It was literally a popularity contest.

Did you pass on a free education on principle? Oh no you just half assed it like most entitled Americans.

Also weak, unimaginative response.
Click to expand...

Define education please.

I thought my response was ribald and a little sophomoric. I'm sorry you were disappointed. Could you give me an example of a better one in keeping with the busting your balls theme I was going for?
 
B

bundee1

Well-Known Member
Rob Roy said:
Define education please.

I thought my response was ribald and a little sophomoric. I'm sorry you were disappointed. Could you give me an example of a better one in keeping with the busting your balls theme I was going for?
Click to expand...
If you're going to bust balls you go for the jugular and if its a good one you will get props. Whenever I hang out with friends we blaze and just burn each other for hours so you have to step it up,

Even a meme will do. Or something along the lines of it must be hard on your shoulder trying to sling that oversized clitoris you call a penis.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top