Do you believe Americans who work full time should earn a living wage?

Do you believe Americans who work full time should earn a living wage?


  • Total voters
    56

tightpockt

Well-Known Member
@Padawanbater2 you keep using words like "should"and "deserve" and those two concepts are irrelevant.
When you say things like "deserve" that means that someone owes you something and you're saying that someone is your employer. Since when is your employer responsible for your living situation? Why does it become an employers responsibility that their employee or the employees parents made bad life choices? Even if you want to blame things like institutionalized racist policies that have detrimental effects that last generations...how does that then become the responsibility of some guy who owns a water ice stand, or a McDonald's franchisee or a fortune 500 company for that matter?

You say "country that has the ability to provide higher wages to workers" but the money isn't coming out of the pockets of 'america' it's business owners your asking to foot the bill for other people.

I try not to make generalizations but I can't help but see patterns in certain ideologies. A lot of people have this parent/child mindset,..where the government or employer or some other group is the parent and thus responsible for your food, clothes, housing and all the other stuff that was provided for you as a child. Some people never grow out of being provided for and now, when they're adults, think they're entitled to something.

I'm not saying it doesn't suck to be born into poverty, those who are definitely start life without the same advantages of those who aren't born into poverty but lets keep it in perspective....If you're born in this country you're already part of the global %1.
For all the faults this country has it still offers more opportunities than almost everywhere else.

Also, what you're 'demanding' is something in return for nothing. You want people with the least amount of skills who applied the least amount of effort to receive more without offering anything in return.

The government has no business in a contract between two people. Of course the government loves the idea because that takes the onus off of them and places is right in the lap of the middle class. Higher minimum wage = more taxable income and less welfare. Which brings up another point. Most adults living off of minimum wage are also receiving welfare benefits that provide food assistance, cash assistance, housing, utilities, medical and a whole host of other programs. Should these people still receive all of this support once they're making more money? If not, they're right back to being dirt poor again after expenses... so what's the point?

For the guy who said he's working 50 hours a week and only bringing home $460...you made the wrong choices, unless you're happy with your circumstances in which case you made the right choices. If it's that shitty then just get another job..you still have choices, you still have opportunities to make moves that might lead to more money. When you break it down and look at all the reasons why you are where you are who's responsible ultimately?
 

superloud

Well-Known Member
@Padawanbater2 you keep using words like "should"and "deserve" and those two concepts are irrelevant.
When you say things like "deserve" that means that someone owes you something and you're saying that someone is your employer. Since when is your employer responsible for your living situation? Why does it become an employers responsibility that their employee or the employees parents made bad life choices? Even if you want to blame things like institutionalized racist policies that have detrimental effects that last generations...how does that then become the responsibility of some guy who owns a water ice stand, or a McDonald's franchisee or a fortune 500 company for that matter?

You say "country that has the ability to provide higher wages to workers" but the money isn't coming out of the pockets of 'america' it's business owners your asking to foot the bill for other people.

I try not to make generalizations but I can't help but see patterns in certain ideologies. A lot of people have this parent/child mindset,..where the government or employer or some other group is the parent and thus responsible for your food, clothes, housing and all the other stuff that was provided for you as a child. Some people never grow out of being provided for and now, when they're adults, think they're entitled to something.

I'm not saying it doesn't suck to be born into poverty, those who are definitely start life without the same advantages of those who aren't born into poverty but lets keep it in perspective....If you're born in this country you're already part of the global %1.
For all the faults this country has it still offers more opportunities than almost everywhere else.

Also, what you're 'demanding' is something in return for nothing. You want people with the least amount of skills who applied the least amount of effort to receive more without offering anything in return.

The government has no business in a contract between two people. Of course the government loves the idea because that takes the onus off of them and places is right in the lap of the middle class. Higher minimum wage = more taxable income and less welfare. Which brings up another point. Most adults living off of minimum wage are also receiving welfare benefits that provide food assistance, cash assistance, housing, utilities, medical and a whole host of other programs. Should these people still receive all of this support once they're making more money? If not, they're right back to being dirt poor again after expenses... so what's the point?

For the guy who said he's working 50 hours a week and only bringing home $460...you made the wrong choices, unless you're happy with your circumstances in which case you made the right choices. If it's that shitty then just get another job..you still have choices, you still have opportunities to make moves that might lead to more money. When you break it down and look at all the reasons why you are where you are who's responsible ultimately?
I don't see why people say we feel Entitled. Or we are asking for them to give us money. The point is the hard working Americans not the lazy people sitting there just begging for money but hard working Americans that built this country do not get paid enough. You should get paid the proper amount of money for the job you do. And no matter what job that is the amount of money you make should be enough to live on. Like im living but if thing keep going the way they are i willbe in debt when i die. and i work hard
 

tightpockt

Well-Known Member
I don't see why people say we feel Entitled. Or we are asking for them to give us money. The point is the hard working Americans not the lazy people sitting there just begging for money but hard working Americans that built this country do not get paid enough. You should get paid the proper amount of money for the job you do. And no matter what job that is the amount of money you make should be enough to live on. Like im living but if thing keep going the way they are i willbe in debt when i die. and i work hard
So get a different fucking job! Jesus...this mindset is driving me crazy.
Generally when people ask for a raise they highlight what they can bring to the table and how they can benefit the company. There's a give and take. It's usually I deserve more money because I do this for the company and these are the skills which I bring to the table which took YEARS to cultivate and in a lot of cases hundreds of thousands of dollars to acquire. They don't go into their bosses office and say I deserve a raise because I want more money.
 

superloud

Well-Known Member
So get a different fucking job! Jesus...this mindset is driving me crazy.
Generally when people ask for a raise they highlight what they can bring to the table and how they can benefit the company. There's a give and take. It's usually I deserve more money because I do this for the company and these are the skills which I bring to the table which took YEARS to cultivate and in a lot of cases hundreds of thousands of dollars to acquire. They don't go into their bosses office and say I deserve a raise because I want more money.
I deserve a raise because I keep my company running. Without me or other people like me then everything you do in this country doesn't happen. The people that run your grocery stores the people that run your factory that create everything you use they don't get paid enough. So you're saying just because maybe someone is not as intelligent as someone else because you know someone not smart enough to become a doctor they don't deserve enough money to be able to live on? And I always love that saying go find another job. I could find other jobs very easily but they would pay as much if not less than What I already get paid. And the problem really isn't the pay in this country the problem is how much everything cost. How much health insurance costs and house payment cost and utility bills and groceries that's the problem. Making $200 a week would not be bad if groceries didn't cost a hundred dollars a week. But I'm sure the only reason you're having this conversation is because you're one of the privileged. And I know there are people that go from being homeless to being doctors and lawyers and shit like that. But not everyone has the same opportunities. See I can't quit my job to go to school because I have bills to pay and a child to take care of. I can't go to school after I get off work because my wife goes to work as soon as I get home. So I have to stay home and take care of my daughter. There is no job that is worth millions of dollars a year compared to someone flipping burgers at McDonald's for 17000 a. year
 

Carolina Dream'n

Well-Known Member
Matt Walsh can go fuck himself

This article was shit, for example;


"Instead, I want to talk to those of you who actually consider yourselves entitled to close to a $29,000 a year full-time salary for doing a job that requires no skill, no expertise and no education; those who think a fry cook ought to earn an entry-level income similar to a dental assistant; those who insist the guy putting the lettuce on my Big Mac ought to make more than the emergency medical technician who saves lives for a living; those who believe you should automatically be able to “live comfortably,” as if “comfort” is a human right."

"no skill" - fast food work requires "no skill"?

I'm not really sure what Mr. Walsh means by "no expertise" here, as if running a corporation into the ground like the financial exec's responsible for the 2008 wall street recession did requires "expertise".. but I digress..

"no education"? - as if an illiterate member of society could just walk in off the streets and start working any fast food position without any training or education and provide equal service..

The fact that fast food workers are demanding a salary equal to that of dental assistants is a testament to how unreasonably low wages are, even for fuckin' dental assistants. Yet somehow he thinks the opposite, that dental assistants, who spend vast amounts of time and money training to be proficient in their profession deserve such low wages. This proves that even if fast food workers received as much training and education as dental assistants (who receive vast amounts), Walsh still wouldn't think they deserve a legitimate living wage.

"When I was 20 I moved out of the house and got my first job in radio. Starting out as a rock DJ in Delaware, I made $17,000 a year, or about $8 an hour. I lived off of that, earning a few small raises through the years — having to eat fewer meals, buy fewer things, and, God forbid, even forgo cable and Internet access in my apartment — right up to when I got married at 25."

Notice the implication; that poor people spend their money on lucrative things, and that's why they're poor (but he didn't, that's why he's not...)

Not to mention the fact that this guy is claiming he survived, in 2007, on an annual salary of only $17,000.. that equals $354/week = $1,416/month. "Fair market price" for a 2 bedroom in Delaware in 2007 = $812/mo, sub utilities, sub car insurance/car payment, sub school loans, sub, misc. costs.. come on.. This idiot is lying through his teeth and anyone whose lived on their own knows it.

"Around my 26th birthday, over 10 years after my first job, I landed a position in Kentucky that paid me around $40,000. It was the first time I’d ever made the equivalent of $15 an hour or more. Again, this was after 10 years of working. Of course, our newfound wealth soon had to be split between four people, as my wife became pregnant with our twins within a few months of me starting the job."

The same reasoning is implied; I earned my wealth through a lot of hard work and time, and that since all these poor people are poor, they must not have spent their time working as hard or as long as I did; fuck them!

"After finding out that we were expecting not one baby, but two, I started my website. I wrote every day for six months before I made much more than a dime on it. It wasn't until August 2013 that I earned my first significant chunk of money. By my 27th birthday last year, I was finally making a “comfortable living.”

It took me over a decade to get here."

What do you think that decade would have looked like if you were black, Mr. Walsh, who believes equal opportunity is rampant here in the good ol' US of A...? (you fucking absolute retard)

"You think the jobs I had when I was 16 should have provided me with the comfortable living I just established in my late 20s? Frankly, I think you're delusional.""

Yes, I do, and frankly, I don't give a shit what you think.

EVERY JOB IN AMERICA, I'm not sure if you heard me correctly, so let me restate it.. EVERY GODDAMN MOTHERFUCKING JOB WITHIN THE BORDERS OF AMERICA SHOULD PAY A MOTHERFUCKING LIVING WAGE. THAT MEANS, WHEREVER THE FUCK YOU LIVE, YOU ARE PROVIDED WITH A WAGE THAT CAN PAY YOUR BILLS.
You can live off 1400 a month. I did it for 2 years. How happy you can be with little money speaks on your own character. As Americans we think we have the right to stuff, that is far from a right, and is actually a privilege.
 

superloud

Well-Known Member
You can live off 1400 a month. I did it for 2 years. How happy you can be with little money speaks on your own character. As Americans we think we have the right to stuff, that is far from a right, and is actually a privilege.
With all the money in this world people should not have to live Like that. I don't think doctors and people working at McDonalds should get paid the same. But I do not believe the pay gap should be millions of dollars a year for some of these corporate people.Want somebody that is working just as hard or even harder than that person is making 20000 a year working at a factory. I should be able to work the job I have and be able to afford nutritional food for my child to eat for me to eat instead I have to buy processed crap like Frozen meals and fast food and shit like that. Because it is a lot cheaper than the alternative of buying fresh meat and vegetables to make good food for my child and me. I should be able to have AC in my house so its not 80 degrees in here where my child has to live all day and I should be able to have heat in my house So I did not have to worry about my child get hyperthermia in the middle of the night. And I do have heat and AC but my electric bill stays a month passed do all the time. I just pay what little bit I can Every week
 

Carolina Dream'n

Well-Known Member
With all the money in this world people should not have to live Like that. I don't think doctors and people working at McDonalds should get paid the same. But I do not believe the pay gap should be millions of dollars a year for some of these corporate people.Want somebody that is working just as hard or even harder than that person is making 20000 a year working at a factory. I should be able to work the job I have and be able to afford nutritional food for my child to eat for me to eat instead I have to buy processed crap like Frozen meals and fast food and shit like that. Because it is a lot cheaper than the alternative of buying fresh meat and vegetables to make good food for my child and me. I should be able to have AC in my house so its not 80 degrees in here where my child has to live all day and I should be able to have heat in my house So I did not have to worry about my child get hyperthermia in the middle of the night. And I do have heat and AC but my electric bill stays a month passed do all the time. I just pay what little bit I can Every week
Ac and heat are privileges. Not rights. We take so much for granted that we bitch about the things we don't have. I hate it. Got clothes on your back, a roof over your head and any food to eat, idc what it is, your better off than half of the WORLD population. Kids with no house would slap Americans across the face for saying "my HOUSE is 80 degrees". They don't have a house to complain about it being hot. Sometimes we need to take a step back and look at things in a different light or perspective.
 

superloud

Well-Known Member
Ac and heat are privileges. Not rights. We take so much for granted that we bitch about the things we don't have. I hate it. Got clothes on your back, a roof over your head and any food to eat, idc what it is, your better off than half of the WORLD population. Kids with no house would slap Americans across the face for saying "my HOUSE is 80 degrees". They don't have a house to complain about it being hot. Sometimes we need to take a step back and look at things in a different light or perspective.
I don't need to look at things that another perspective because I do not live in those countries. I live in America and the bottom line is it is not right that there are people making millions of dollars while I make 20000 dollars a year. It is not right that their people living like kings while there people living in the street. And the person living in the street works harder than the king. I'm not asking to be giving anything. It is just my opinion that i should be payed more for what i do
 

Red1966

Well-Known Member
What if your employer decides your skills are worth $.05/day? I hear you already "I'll get another employer", OK, and that guy agrees, yep, your skills are worth about $.05/day, so that's what you get. See where this is going...? What's stopping employers from devaluing your skills and paying you peanuts?
They won't be able to get employees. You just can't stand the fact that no one thinks you're worth minimum wage, Mr. "I can only dream of making $900 a month".
 

see4

Well-Known Member
Lol@living on 1400 a month.... I guess it depends were you live. Some places 1400 don't even cover a one bedroom apt
Boston, NYC, Chicago, Miami, LA -- $1,400/month barely gets you a closet. Literally.

...people making millions of dollars while I make 20000 dollars a year. It is not right that their people living like kings while there people living in the street...
Compensation commensurate of education and experience.
 

superloud

Well-Known Member
Boston, NYC, Chicago, Miami, LA -- $1,400/month barely gets you a closet. Literally.



Compensation commensurate of education and experience.
Yes but the proportion difference is absurd. And like I said before just because someone is not smart enough to go to college and become a businessman Doesn't mean that he Shouldn't be able to live comfortably. If they go out and get a job and work there at asses off running the backbone of America.
 

Red1966

Well-Known Member
I don't need to look at things that another perspective because I do not live in those countries. I live in America and the bottom line is it is not right that there are people making millions of dollars while I make 20000 dollars a year. It is not right that their people living like kings while there people living in the street. And the person living in the street works harder than the king. I'm not asking to be giving anything. It is just my opinion that i should be payed more for what i do
Those millioaires you complain about think they should paid more, too. Everybody thinks they should be paid more.
 

Red1966

Well-Known Member
Yes but the proportion difference is absurd. And like I said before just because someone is not smart enough to go to college and become a businessman Doesn't mean that he Shouldn't be able to live comfortably. If they go out and get a job and work there at asses off running the backbone of America.
What about the slackers who think just showing up is all they need to do?
 

see4

Well-Known Member
Yes but the proportion difference is absurd.
100% Agree.

And like I said before just because someone is not smart enough to go to college and become a businessman Doesn't mean that he Shouldn't be able to live comfortably. If they go out and get a job and work there at asses off running the backbone of America.
This is hard to respond to as it is broadly categorizing everyone not living comfortably. This subject is rather complicated as there are many permutations that account for an almost unlimited number of situations.

If you grew up with a parent or parents who were blue collar working class and you lived ok, but never was able to afford college, then I agree you should be able to work and live a comfortable life. But that's subjective.

If you grew up with well-to-do parents and could have gone to college but chose not to, and you spent a few years "exploring yourself", and now you whine about living a comfortable life, I don't feel bad for you at all.
 
Top