Ive lived in and between Detroit and Ann Arbor pretty much my entire life. Been in city schools and rural schools, I was the first in my family to go to college with no understanding of what I was doing outside of wrestling and dropped out with a 1.6 GPA. I met the girl that would become my wife. She is pretty much the same, but her dad and mom both have degrees and she ended up going to about 4 different ones dropping out of each before we both dropped out and started waiting tables full time.
After a few years we decided we needed a change from the retail assistant management pathway I was on and her thinking about being a tattoo artist or hair dresser. I worked and put her through school for 7 years, she kicked ass, and is now has a Doctor of Pharmacy.
I went back and got as far as a couple years into a PhD in Statistics, MA in Econometrics and a BS in Actuarial Mathematics.
The highest math class I had prior to returning was geometry in High school, I had 7th graders in my math class as a senior, it was pretty embarrassing.
What happened? The poor kids with no upbringing outran the school. They made it as bad as the school they left. The teachers have no control and are verbally abused and threatened when their kids misbehave. What good did this do? In my opinion, nothing...
My guess would be a combination of those kids having no actual preparation for the enviroment they were walking into and a percentage in the community that was pissed about having to do this got some confirmation bias. People see anything that is not instant success that they don't want to do as confirmation that what is being done is crap.
But life is a game of inches, the goal is for everyone to get a little better results than they would have anyways, or at least the same amount of results. Those kids coming to the better schools are doing so to be better able to be prepared to go to a college when they graduate. If they are that bad, keeping them all pooled up in a underfunded school is not helping them at all.
may be called racist for saying so, but the schools primarily black have much more problems and lower scores. The school my nieces go to was primarily white, until the new law passed, now its 75% black and have went downhill fast.
That is the problem and why reparations being studied is a good thing for our country to do. People are people, you said so yourself, it is not a racial problem. Its a economic problem. By helping these communities who are still reeling from racist laws enacted by our government we would be saving the country so much money while increasing our productivity. This does not hurt white people, nothing is being taken away from them, it is just being sold as that being the case by racist propaganda.