1) Jennifer Garner - hands down my favorite. Actually dated a girl in college for short time that looked a lot like her.
2) Jenna Fischer (plays Pam on the Office)
3) Natalie Portman - like that she's smart, but she went to Harvard so I don't like that she might be smarter than me, lol. Same major as me too.
Honorable Mentions:
Ellen Page ("Juno") - Especially like that movie since both her and Jennifer Garner were in it, haha. And no I'm not some sicko Ellen Page was like 20 when she was in that movie.
Diane Kruger - ("National Treasure") dated a girl that looked a little like her too except with darker hair.
Keri Russell
Jennifer Aniston - absolute knock out, but I'm on the fence with her. She's definitely "girl next door" material, but she's so famous I don't know how "real" she is. And come on, how could you even come close to replacing Brad Pitt...
I'm really down with the "girl next door" look. Type of girls you might work with or see at the grocery store. Don't get me wrong, women like Megan Fox are sexy as hell, but I feel women that famous and beautiful aren't "real" people like you or I.
A lot of ppl say she is ugly and has a man face, but there is something about Fergie from the Black Eye Peas that I really like. Regardless, she's got a bangin body.