OK, first off I wasn't telling you what do I was merely giving my advice based off what I do and learned from many growers that have been doing this for years and know there shit, one of the guys I learned this "Rule of Thumb" from is literally a Plant Guru, he has a degree in botany and he's been studying plants and plant science since he was twelve and he's now 36, this guy has forgotten more about plants than either of us will ever know, he was like the 10th person to tell me about the "Rule of Thumb" 1 month of growth per gal so it would be pretty ignorant of me to not heed there advice, if three (and especially more) experienced professionals agree on something its practically guaranteed to be sound advice. Now even if your doing SOG keeping them short with basically one cola per plant I assure you 1gal pots is not as you put it "Just right", your going to have a minimum (depending on strain) of 6-8weeks flowering time so after 1month of growth the roots are going to start to get bound and after 2months they absolutely will be, if you think that doesn't prevent the plants from reaching their maximum potential then I don't know what to tell you. Also, if you only grow based off "your experiences" and not "the next persons experiences" then why are you even here on this forum, just to boast, because what your basically saying is you can't take anyone's advice because your only growing based off "your experiences" right? That's just asinine IMHO, there is soooo much about plants we still don't know and were making advancements and discoveries every day, new techniques, new equipment, new ways to do things, how can you ever evolve if you have the mind set that your way is the only way??? I will check back in 8wks like you said, however I doubt I'll learn anything I don't already know, If I do though I'm a big enough man to put my foot in my mouth and say you told me so, however I'm so confident that's not going to happen that I'm not going to wash my feet for the next 8wks, LMFAO!!