The Other Best DIY Carbon Filter

|B3RNY|

Well-Known Member
(Note: Please read the entire post before you begin.)

Let me start by first apologizing for producing yet another D.I.Y. carbon filter, I'm terribly sorry but most of the other do-it-yourself filter tutorials I've found are lacking something (usually they're just unorganized & constructed poorly.) Carbon filters are much more affordable than they used to be, so constructing your own may not always save you money.
I also wanted to stress the importance of odor control, as well as the effectiveness of activated carbon air scrubbers to those new in the field (or those who are skeptical); as long as an adequate amount of activated carbon & the proper sized extraction fan are used in combination, a carbon filter will keep all odors contained inside of the room in which it operates. Activated carbon can remove about 99.9% of airborne particles.

Before you begin building anything, it is very important to figure out the right dimensions (& fan size) for your application, or else the filter will not work as efficiently. This tutorial can be used as a rough guideline to build/modify your own carbon filter creation. Multiply Length X Width X Height = Volume (in Feet) to figure out what size fan you will need- inline fans are rated in C.F.M.'s (Cubic Feet Per Minute.) In an ideal setting, a grow room exhaust fan would exchange all of the air in the room 2-3 times per minute (removes odors & can lower temperatures); it's your choice but I recommend that you use a fan that can move all of the air in the room once every 5 minutes, as a minimum (removes odors.) Typically one would use a 4" fan on a small room or closet, a 6" fan on a bigger space and an 8"+ (or even multiple 6" fans) for a large room; those measurements refer to the diameter of the fan's flange- bigger fans usually move more air = higher C.F.M. rating. Invest in the highest quality fan that you can afford.

I borrowed (& modified) this guide from another thread but it is quite useful. If your C.F.M. rating is not listed then choose the C.F.M. rating that is the closest to your own, divide by the corresponding height (example: 200 C.F.M./12= 16.6.) Then divide your C.F.M. rating by the resulting number (16.6) to figure your recommended core height. I recommend that you use the following diameters as closely as possible: for <220 C.F.M. = 4&#8221;; 221-475 C.F.M. = 6&#8221;; 476-600 C.F.M. = 8&#8221;; >600 = 10&#8221;&#8230; I also recommend that you use a carbon thickness of at least 2&#8221;, by using a shell diameter 2&#8221; wider than your core diameter.

It's better to use a fan/filter combo that's too large, rather than one too small.

Legend:
D = Inner Core Diameter (In Inches)
H = Filter's Height (In Inches)
IC = Inner Core (Surface Area- Inches Squared)

C.F.M.|D |H | IC |
150 |4 | 9 |113 |= (CFM/Height= 16.6)
200 |4 |12|151 |= (CFM/Height= 16.6)
275 |6 |12|226 |= (CFM/Height= 22.91)
375 |6 |16|302 |= (CFM/Height= 23.43)
400 |6 |24|603 |= (CFM/Height= 16.6)
550 |8 |24|603 |= (CFM/Height= 22.91)
650 |10|24|754 |= (CFM/Height= 27)


Gather supplies...

Materials Needed:

Hardware Store:
*Duct Tape (Duh.)
*Metal Snips or Strong Scissors
*Small (4") Ducting End Cap
*Large (6") Ducting End Cap
*1 6"-4" Duct Reducer
*1 4" Duct Collar
*1 Roll 1/4" Hardware Cloth (Stronger Than Wire Mesh (Which Will Sag))
*2 4" Hose Clamps
*2 6" Hose Clamps

Department Store:
*Plenty of Activated Carbon (Pet/Aquarium Isle)
*Pantyhose (Preferably New)
*Quilt Batting Material
*4" Flexible Ducting
*Inline Fan, extractor or Duct Booster-Fan
*A Couple O' Tools (A Flat Head Screwdriver is Required for the Hose Clamps)



1. Stay Organized...
000_0008.jpg
(Pictured: Clockwise from left- 1/4" Wire Mesh, Black Pantyhose, 6"-4" Duct Reducer, 6" & 4" Hose Clamps, 2 Jars of Activated Carbon, 6" Duct Cap, 4" Duct Cap, 4" Duct Collar, Duct Tape)

2. Cut some wire mesh as wide as the desired length of your filter (mine will be 12"), as long as the circumference of your large duct cap (4&#8221; fan = 12.5, 6&#8221; = 19, 8&#8221; = 25, 10&#8221; = 31.5 (circumference in inches)), plus 1 inch. It&#8217;ll be easier if you make this cut against the curl of the wire mesh, because it will help if you use the natural curve of the mesh to wrap it around the large duct cap, forming a cylinder as in the picture (the outer shell of the carbon filter.) Don&#8217;t forget to cut it a little long; you need it to overlap so that you can secure it together. You can even double wrap the mesh to make a stronger filter, but it will hold up nice & sturdy regardless. Secure the cylinder to the end cap with a hose clamp, hold the other end in its cylindrical form and use thin wire, string or the wiry edges of the wire mesh to secure the wire mesh in its cylindrical form. I fastened my cylinder in place using the wire that came laced through the wire mesh (to keep it from unraveling), by weaving it tightly through the overlapped edge. Throughout the entire process, focus on wrapping & securing everything neatly & tightly, with good, clean edges. Leave the other end open for now, (use my photos for reference; I apologize, I didn&#8217;t take as many pictures as I would have liked.)

000_0010.jpg
(Outer Shell)

3. Use the same method to cut some wire mesh for the inner cylinder. Cut it to length (the length of your filter (12&#8221;)) and to width (the circumference of the inner cylindrical shell, remember to add in inch or so) 4" X 3.14 + 1~ 13.5". Wrap the "width" side of the mesh around the 4" duct cap, forming another cylinder, and slide on/tighten one of the 4" hose clamps over the mesh, securing it to the duct cap (as shown.) Use more wire (or the 'male' ends of the wire mesh) to secure the round shape of the inner wall; remove the hose clamp, stretch 1 length of the cut pantyhose (carefully) over the cylinder & reattach the hose clamp to secure the mesh & pantyhose. Proceed to insert the 4" duct collar to the other end and tighten a 4" hose clamp over the mesh/pantyhose on that end as well.
Your core should look something like this:

000_0009.jpg
(The Inner Core)

4. Insert the duct collar on the inner cylinder into the inside of the duct reducer and stuff the inside with the cotton/quilt batting around 2" or so thick (until it is level/flush with the 4" duct collar&#8230; this is where the air flow will begin& the material will help keep the carbon granules in place.) Now rest assured, the most labor-intensive part is over.


000_0011.jpg
(Carbon Filter Core, Outer Shell & Duct Tape)

5. Now that both of the major parts of the carbon filter are made, you can fit them together. Slide the open side of the 6" shell over the 6" side of the reducer and use the last 6" hose clamp to fasten them together. This should give you a carbon filter frame that resembles something of this nature:

100_0049.jpg
(Completed Carbon Filter Body)

6. Now to fill (and refill) your carbon filter, simply loosen the hose clamp on the bottom of the filter, remove the duct cap and pour activated carbon on top of the quilt batting in-between the 2 mesh cylinders, stopping about 1.5" before it is full and fill the rest with more quilt batting/material to keep the carbon granules from moving around/falling out. I made a 'pre-filter' by cutting a strip of the quilt batting material to wrap around the outside of the filter, beneath the hose clamps. It will make the filter look a little more professional and will filter out large particles in the air, making your carbon last longer (extra pantyhose can be used here in place of the batting.)

You can caulk the inside of the filter where the duct reducer meets the 4" collar to make a good seal, ensuring your carbon is being used efficiently. I caulked all of the seals on my filter, except the end that needs to be removed for refilling. Another good tip is to put a strip of duct tape around each cylinder end, beneath the hose clamps so that they (the hose clamps) don't bend/distort the wire mesh cylinders too bad... it also seems to make them more solid & reduce noise/vibration.

100_0052.jpg
(A Look Inside of The Finished Filter)

Here's a look at the final product, ready to be strapped to an exhaust fan and cranked up. Here you can see how the duct tape was used beneath the hose clamps. Even though only the carbon between the strips of tape on each end is being used efficiently- she still served her purpose well. Just like a name brand carbon filter, the first time you start it up (& after refilling- it will blow out a little carbon dust.)

100E0038.jpg
(Voila!)


A refining touch: when my filter was finished, I later went back and took it all apart to modify it a little bit. I wrapped another piece of wire mesh around the inner core & the outer shell, so that each pair of pantyhose had 1 layer of wire mesh on each side of it... this greatly improved the structural integrity of the filter itself and helped hold the pantyhose in place.
Make sure to complete each step as neatly & tightly as possible to get the best results. If you use a fan that is to small- the motor will burn out more quickly, if your fan is too large the carbon will be used up too quickly (& not nearly as efficiently.) Carbon can be found in large quantities on auctions sites, such as eBay.


I built this filter several years ago. At the time, I was using a 4" 80 C.F.M. duct booster fan but I knew that I was going to upgrade that so I built my filter to such a dimension/carbon thickness that it would allow for such an upgrade without complications (which is why I strayed a bit from the guidelines given.)

000_0007.jpg
(It's better to pull air through you filter than to push it.)

"...where credit is due", this is the tutorial that inspired my creation:
http://www.icmag.com/ic/showthread.php?t=31679
(from a guy named DurbanPoison, he took more pictures and made a nice tutorial as well though the final product was a bit sloppy in appearance.)
 

Attachments

|B3RNY|

Well-Known Member
Thanks man, I have since given that filter away; I just wanted to show how simply these filters are made. The DIY filters work just as good, when they're constructed well and everything is good an airtight (other than where the airflow begins/ends.)
 

|B3RNY|

Well-Known Member
I don't remember exactly what it cost because it's been a while, but it was around 40-50 dollars; that left me with about 3/4 left on the roll of hardware cloth (which was like $20-25 of the total cost), so I could build even more of em- or maybe a bigger one... you can buy wire mesh for a little cheaper but it's not as strong. Thanks for the +Rep, back atcha.
 

plantz

Well-Known Member
Just followed this guide and made my own, it came out great and looks very nice! I havn't had a chance to use it yet, but i highly recommend it!

+rep berny for going out of your way to bring this to RIU, again, thank you so much!
 

|B3RNY|

Well-Known Member
Thanks man, I'm glad to hear it... let us know how that works out for ya. It should serve you well!
 

IlovePlants

Well-Known Member
I know this is going to sound weird, but has anyone used charred bird feathers as their activated carbon?

A while ago I had read that scientists where trying to create a hydrogen fuel cell that had a more maximized internal surface area, giving a place for the hydrogen to settle while being stored.

http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/06/090623120833.htm

Anyway, I figured it would be a great way to get activated carbon, since activated carbon is essentially carbon with a high surface area.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Activated_carbon

For people who own chickens, or choose to clean out farmers hen houses for free ferts, this seems like a create way to get insanely cheap on activated carbon.
Really awesome design, I like this better than the pencil cup one because it seems almost as easy to assemble, but due to the materials you could make a filter the exact size that you need. Keep up the amazing DIY work!
Sincerely,
ILovePlants
 

|B3RNY|

Well-Known Member
Thanks, I had not ever heard of the bird feathers before... that's pretty interesting, have you tried it before?
 

IlovePlants

Well-Known Member
I have not, although I have been out of state for the last few weeks, and will be employing this idea when I return. I will let you know how it goes.

ILovePlants
 
Hey my filter looks great but confused on amount of carbon needed? Does the Activated carbon totally fill the space between the 4 inch cylinder and the 6 inch cylinder? I bought 1 pound of activated carbon on the eBay But it looks like I need a whole lot more than that. Im a newbie so i got a lot to learn.....Thanks!






(Note: Please read the entire post before you begin.)

Let me start by first apologizing for producing yet another D.I.Y. carbon filter, I'm terribly sorry but most of the other do-it-yourself filter tutorials I've found are lacking something (usually they're just unorganized & constructed poorly.) Carbon filters are much more affordable than they used to be, so constructing your own may not always save you money.
I also wanted to stress the importance of odor control, as well as the effectiveness of activated carbon air scrubbers to those new in the field (or those who are skeptical); as long as an adequate amount of activated carbon & the proper sized extraction fan are used in combination, a carbon filter will keep all odors contained inside of the room in which it operates. Activated carbon can remove about 99.9% of airborne particles.

Before you begin building anything, it is very important to figure out the right dimensions (& fan size) for your application, or else the filter will not work as efficiently. This tutorial can be used as a rough guideline to build/modify your own carbon filter creation. Multiply Length X Width X Height = Volume (in Feet) to figure out what size fan you will need- inline fans are rated in C.F.M.'s (Cubic Feet Per Minute.) In an ideal setting, a grow room exhaust fan would exchange all of the air in the room 2-3 times per minute (removes odors & can lower temperatures); it's your choice but I recommend that you use a fan that can move all of the air in the room once every 5 minutes, as a minimum (removes odors.) Typically one would use a 4" fan on a small room or closet, a 6" fan on a bigger space and an 8"+ (or even multiple 6" fans) for a large room; those measurements refer to the diameter of the fan's flange- bigger fans usually move more air = higher C.F.M. rating. Invest in the highest quality fan that you can afford.

I borrowed (& modified) this guide from another thread but it is quite useful. If your C.F.M. rating is not listed then choose the C.F.M. rating that is the closest to your own, divide by the corresponding height (example: 200 C.F.M./12= 16.6.) Then divide your C.F.M. rating by the resulting number (16.6) to figure your recommended core height. I recommend that you use the following diameters as closely as possible: for <220 C.F.M. = 4”; 221-475 C.F.M. = 6”; 476-600 C.F.M. = 8”; >600 = 10”… I also recommend that you use a carbon thickness of at least 2”, by using a shell diameter 2” wider than your core diameter.

It's better to use a fan/filter combo that's too large, rather than one too small.

Legend:
D = Inner Core Diameter (In Inches)
H = Filter's Height (In Inches)
IC = Inner Core (Surface Area- Inches Squared)

C.F.M.|D |H | IC |
150 |4 | 9 |113 |= (CFM/Height= 16.6)
200 |4 |12|151 |= (CFM/Height= 16.6)
275 |6 |12|226 |= (CFM/Height= 22.91)
375 |6 |16|302 |= (CFM/Height= 23.43)
400 |6 |24|603 |= (CFM/Height= 16.6)
550 |8 |24|603 |= (CFM/Height= 22.91)
650 |10|24|754 |= (CFM/Height= 27)


Gather supplies...

Materials Needed:

Hardware Store:
*Duct Tape (Duh.)
*Metal Snips or Strong Scissors
*Small (4") Ducting End Cap
*Large (6") Ducting End Cap
*1 6"-4" Duct Reducer
*1 4" Duct Collar
*1 Roll 1/4" Hardware Cloth (Stronger Than Wire Mesh (Which Will Sag))
*2 4" Hose Clamps
*2 6" Hose Clamps

Department Store:
*Plenty of Activated Carbon (Pet/Aquarium Isle)
*Pantyhose (Preferably New)
*Quilt Batting Material
*4" Flexible Ducting
*Inline Fan, extractor or Duct Booster-Fan
*A Couple O' Tools (A Flat Head Screwdriver is Required for the Hose Clamps)



1. Stay Organized...
View attachment 2317077
(Pictured: Clockwise from left- 1/4" Wire Mesh, Black Pantyhose, 6"-4" Duct Reducer, 6" & 4" Hose Clamps, 2 Jars of Activated Carbon, 6" Duct Cap, 4" Duct Cap, 4" Duct Collar, Duct Tape)

2. Cut some wire mesh as wide as the desired length of your filter (mine will be 12"), as long as the circumference of your large duct cap (4” fan = 12.5, 6” = 19, 8” = 25, 10” = 31.5 (circumference in inches)), plus 1 inch. It’ll be easier if you make this cut against the curl of the wire mesh, because it will help if you use the natural curve of the mesh to wrap it around the large duct cap, forming a cylinder as in the picture (the outer shell of the carbon filter.) Don’t forget to cut it a little long; you need it to overlap so that you can secure it together. You can even double wrap the mesh to make a stronger filter, but it will hold up nice & sturdy regardless. Secure the cylinder to the end cap with a hose clamp, hold the other end in its cylindrical form and use thin wire, string or the wiry edges of the wire mesh to secure the wire mesh in its cylindrical form. I fastened my cylinder in place using the wire that came laced through the wire mesh (to keep it from unraveling), by weaving it tightly through the overlapped edge. Throughout the entire process, focus on wrapping & securing everything neatly & tightly, with good, clean edges. Leave the other end open for now, (use my photos for reference; I apologize, I didn’t take as many pictures as I would have liked.)

View attachment 2317079
(Outer Shell)

3. Use the same method to cut some wire mesh for the inner cylinder. Cut it to length (the length of your filter (12”)) and to width (the circumference of the inner cylindrical shell, remember to add in inch or so) 4" X 3.14 + 1~ 13.5". Wrap the "width" side of the mesh around the 4" duct cap, forming another cylinder, and slide on/tighten one of the 4" hose clamps over the mesh, securing it to the duct cap (as shown.) Use more wire (or the 'male' ends of the wire mesh) to secure the round shape of the inner wall; remove the hose clamp, stretch 1 length of the cut pantyhose (carefully) over the cylinder & reattach the hose clamp to secure the mesh & pantyhose. Proceed to insert the 4" duct collar to the other end and tighten a 4" hose clamp over the mesh/pantyhose on that end as well.
Your core should look something like this:

View attachment 2317078
(The Inner Core)

4. Insert the duct collar on the inner cylinder into the inside of the duct reducer and stuff the inside with the cotton/quilt batting around 2" or so thick (until it is level/flush with the 4" duct collar… this is where the air flow will begin& the material will help keep the carbon granules in place.) Now rest assured, the most labor-intensive part is over.


View attachment 2317080
(Carbon Filter Core, Outer Shell & Duct Tape)

5. Now that both of the major parts of the carbon filter are made, you can fit them together. Slide the open side of the 6" shell over the 6" side of the reducer and use the last 6" hose clamp to fasten them together. This should give you a carbon filter frame that resembles something of this nature:

View attachment 2317081
(Completed Carbon Filter Body)

6. Now to fill (and refill) your carbon filter, simply loosen the hose clamp on the bottom of the filter, remove the duct cap and pour activated carbon on top of the quilt batting in-between the 2 mesh cylinders, stopping about 1.5" before it is full and fill the rest with more quilt batting/material to keep the carbon granules from moving around/falling out. I made a 'pre-filter' by cutting a strip of the quilt batting material to wrap around the outside of the filter, beneath the hose clamps. It will make the filter look a little more professional and will filter out large particles in the air, making your carbon last longer (extra pantyhose can be used here in place of the batting.)

You can caulk the inside of the filter where the duct reducer meets the 4" collar to make a good seal, ensuring your carbon is being used efficiently. I caulked all of the seals on my filter, except the end that needs to be removed for refilling. Another good tip is to put a strip of duct tape around each cylinder end, beneath the hose clamps so that they (the hose clamps) don't bend/distort the wire mesh cylinders too bad... it also seems to make them more solid & reduce noise/vibration.

View attachment 2317082
(A Look Inside of The Finished Filter)

Here's a look at the final product, ready to be strapped to an exhaust fan and cranked up. Here you can see how the duct tape was used beneath the hose clamps. Even though only the carbon between the strips of tape on each end is being used efficiently- she still served her purpose well. Just like a name brand carbon filter, the first time you start it up (& after refilling- it will blow out a little carbon dust.)

View attachment 2317083
(Voila!)


A refining touch: when my filter was finished, I later went back and took it all apart to modify it a little bit. I wrapped another piece of wire mesh around the inner core & the outer shell, so that each pair of pantyhose had 1 layer of wire mesh on each side of it... this greatly improved the structural integrity of the filter itself and helped hold the pantyhose in place.
Make sure to complete each step as neatly & tightly as possible to get the best results. If you use a fan that is to small- the motor will burn out more quickly, if your fan is too large the carbon will be used up too quickly (& not nearly as efficiently.) Carbon can be found in large
 

|B3RNY|

Well-Known Member
Hmm.. the carbon needs to fill the space between the 2 cylinders; the amount you need depends on the size that you went with, including height (or length)... the space on the outside that is covered by the lips of the duct caps and/or reducers can be filled with a foam or "quilt guts" .. this keeps the carbon in place a lot better. The air the fan pulls is going to take the easiest route possible to the inside of the filter, so keep that in mind when you're filling it up (make sure that the easiest way for the air to move is evenly throughout the layer of carbon), i it goes through an air pocket or finds an easier way though the quilt batting- it won't filter the air efficiently. A pound of carbon should make a decent size filter; I'm assuming you made yours pretty lengthy? If you stack carbon tall enough that it goes a tiny bit past where the reducer lip ends, you should be able to top it off with quilt batting but make sure you stuff it somewhat tightly.

Other tips-
1. You can mix your carbon with "good" kitty litter (Fresh Step with crystals) or use only kitty litter in your filter and it will clean the air just as good (when filter/fan sizes are ideal), the only downside is that it needs to be replaced more often... if you just needed a bit more carbon, you could take it all out, mix with kitty litter and then ad it to the cylinders until it is full? ..if you don't want to play with kitty litter you can get smaller amounts of carbon at WalMart in the aquarium section.

2. With ANY filter, if it starts to work less efficiently- take the filter down, shake it all around (safely, don't throw carbon everywhere) so the carbon gets rearranged a bit and then hook it back up. This gets a little more life out of filters that would normally be replaced/refilled. This won't work for too awfully long though; carbon filters do not use up the carbon very consistently (there will be spots where the carbon has been 'used up' more in some places than others), so a mix up should help get the most life out of your $.

Good luck, let me know if this helped or if I can help with anything else?

Good growin' to all.
 

hobby1980

Member
I'm guessing this is going to result in me looking like an idiot but what pieces would you replace to use with 6" ducting? (is that a word) Anyway, you use a 6" to 4" reducer. What if I need to stay at 6" for my fan? Can I substitute 6" and 8" for 4" and 6"?
 
Awesome DYI, I will definitely be putting this together. I'm a virgin when it comes to growing, and just got started with my first batch, two sprouts of Blueberry Cush.

I do have a question regarding the carbon scrubber, tho. I've been trying to read up as much as I can before asking, but I really can't find this information anywhere. Hopefully it's not because it's a stupid and obvious question, if so please accept my apology. Anyways, here goes nothing:

I'm setting up my build in the closet, the problem is that there is no exhaust in there. Can I simply make a hole in the door and attach the scrubber to this? Again, this might be a dummy question, but I hope that you can share your collected wisdom with me. One day I hope to be able to give back to this great community, but for right now I'm just a leech ... ;-)

Stay wasted!

/P
 

|B3RNY|

Well-Known Member
Awesome DYI, I will definitely be putting this together. I'm a virgin when it comes to growing, and just got started with my first batch, two sprouts of Blueberry Cush.

I do have a question regarding the carbon scrubber, tho. I've been trying to read up as much as I can before asking, but I really can't find this information anywhere. Hopefully it's not because it's a stupid and obvious question, if so please accept my apology. Anyways, here goes nothing:

I'm setting up my build in the closet, the problem is that there is no exhaust in there. Can I simply make a hole in the door and attach the scrubber to this? Again, this might be a dummy question, but I hope that you can share your collected wisdom with me. One day I hope to be able to give back to this great community, but for right now I'm just a leech ... ;-)

Stay wasted!

/P
That would work just fine.. depending.. you could certainly cut a hole in the door to use but I'd make it an intake hole. If you just make one hole, it will be your intake; ideally, you want an intake & exhaust hole (with the latter being the same size or larger to save fan/motor life.) Just remember (obviously), that only the air that has passed through your filter will be clean. I usually put my filter inside, attached to my exhaust with a passive intake about an inch larger in diameter than my exhaust. Also, try not to vent exhaust directly outside unless you are growing legally (filter into the attic if possible.)
 
Top