Pole: what do you guys think of 50/50 soil and coco?

These threads always end the same.

CTGrown203 said:

I think everyone beginners and experts alike on here need to do some research on what soil actually is soil is Loam so if there’s no loaM it’s not soil it’s soil less with amendments Peat and coco act different but still both soil less

Click to expand...

Again , i may be wrong but i think the term "loam" describes the texture of the soil. not the soil itself. In other words it dont have to be loamy to be called soil. clay is soil too....

CTGrown203 said:

Negative ur lawn is not made of pete moss or coco

Click to expand...

Nobody said it was?
My lawn is clay ish soil.

Peat is still soilless

Peat and RePeat were on a boat....

CTGrown203 said:

Peat is still soilless

Click to expand...

Were waaay past that sir. Everything without soil is soiless. Thats kinda obvious.
You will have to read if you want to contribute.

getogrow said:

Your hard headed like me. Im openly debating and openly admiting that i do not know it all but since you do , i should step back.
I made it very clear that said soil was stripped of nutes both macro and secondary and micro....zero , nada. That makes soil inert .......by the way , whats the definition of inert again ?
The difference is , im over here learning while you sit atop a throne.

At this point you are literally saying if i add N to coco then its not inert anymore. You guys have done cited it being loaded with marcos and micros. I dont see how your calling that inert but hey , im just a soil guy , im not up to you hydro guys yet.

Click to expand...

I don't think you actually know what soil is.

Here's a Wikipedia definition for you: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soil
If that one's too tricky, try this: https://www.soils4kids.org/about
If you fee like really "getting into the weeds" on it, I'd suggest you read the College textbook my professor required 20-some years ago: https://www.amazon.com/Soil-Science-Management-Edward-Plaster/dp/0840024320

The commonality you will see in all of these references is that soil consists of rock mineral particulates, water, air, organic matter, and micro organisms. Again, if you strip soil of it's organic matter it is no longer soil. As I told you before it becomes sand, silt, clay, or a combination of the three, but without organic matter it is certainly not soil.

By the way, I doubt that you grow in soil (unless you are an outdoor grower), more likely you grow in a potting mix, which is very much akin to actual soil in terms of plant growth habits..

getogrow said:

Again , i may be wrong but i think the term "loam" describes the texture of the soil. not the soil itself. In other words it dont have to be loamy to be called soil. clay is soil too....

Click to expand...

Loam is a soil that has even mixtures of sand, silt, and clay particulates, plus organic matter. Loam soils are idea because they have both excellent drainage, and also great nutrient holding capabilities.

getogrow said:

Were waaay past that sir. Everything without soil is soiless. Thats kinda obvious.
You will have to read if you want to contribute.

Click to expand...

Yep, even "potting soil" is soilless most of the time.

PJ Diaz said:

Loam is a soil that has even mixtures of sand, silt, and clay particulates, plus organic matter. Loam soils are idea because they have both excellent drainage, and also great nutrient holding capabilities.

Click to expand...

Thats EXACTLY what i just said.... geez. is it really that hard to agree with the truth ?

PJ Diaz said:

Yep, even "potting soil" is soilless most of the time.

Click to expand...

most potting soil is soiless.... that has nothing to do with the topic.

Im obviously way past you on soil knowledge so you do not understand any of what im trying to say.

Coco is not inert by no means unless you wash and sterlize it....which some companies do.
Have you ever even read the label on your block of coco or are you just still referencing RIU members having success with it as a hydro medium.?

I learned ALL this info from debating with you guys! thank you very much for your time!

getogrow said:

Thats EXACTLY what i just said.... geez. is it really that hard to agree with the truth ?


most potting soil is soiless.... that has nothing to do with the topic.

Im obviously way past you on soil knowledge so you do not understand any of what im trying to say.

Coco is not inert by no means unless you wash and sterlize it....which some companies do.
Have you ever even read the label on your block of coco or are you just still referencing RIU members having success with it as a hydro medium.?

I learned ALL this info from debating with you guys! thank you very much for your time!

Click to expand...

You mad bro? LMFAO

Yeah, I clarified and added substance to your statement about loam. Sorry about that bro, don't take it too hard. FFS LOL

Yeah I reuse my coco over and over. Why buy new when you don't have to?

i know right? It seemed like their was an agreement somewhere in those last few posts

you already learned when you figured out that you cant grow plants in plain coco or peat and plain water - that's really all you need to know

the rest of what youz guyz are talking about are definitions of words so i guess thats what you're learning now?


im a re-user of coco too - surprising how many ppl don't re-use

PJ Diaz said:

Yeah I reuse my coco over and over. Why buy new when you don't have to?

Click to expand...

is this where im supposed to say "you cant reuse coco" ?

just stay close mined and ill keep learning....maybe one day , far away , ill be able to sit on that throne with ya

getogrow said:

is this where im supposed to say "you cant reuse coco" ?

just stay close mined and ill keep learning....maybe one day , far away , ill be able to sit on that throne with ya

Click to expand...

no it's "you can't overwater coco"

you guys crack me up - i like you both believe it or not

HaroldRocks said:

you guys crack me up - i like you both believe it or not

Click to expand...

i get a bit defensive sometimes , like most , but for the most part i try to stay on folks good side. Ive seen the guy im debating all over the forums , very bright dude is why im still here....
Either way none of its a big deal and i prolly should of shut my mouth a few pages back. Fuckin way she goes boys.

soil

Derp

getogrow said:

i get a bit defensive sometimes , like most , but for the most part i try to stay on folks good side. Ive seen the guy im debating all over the forums , very bright dude is why im still here....
Either way none of its a big deal and i prolly should of shut my mouth a few pages back. Fuckin way she goes boys.

soil

Click to expand...

Thats it Ray

PadawanWarrior said:

I'm a master baiter.

Click to expand...

Fuck, you too?

getogrow said:

i get a bit defensive sometimes , like most , but for the most part i try to stay on folks good side. Ive seen the guy im debating all over the forums , very bright dude is why im still here....
Either way none of its a big deal and i prolly should of shut my mouth a few pages back. Fuckin way she goes boys.

soil

Click to expand...

all good - you're just giving a point of view that's not by the book - nothing wrong with that...


so why do you have that xtsho quote in your sig?