Why would you check it against a strip test kit? Buy some ph 7 calibration fluid and actually know how far its off or recalibrate.
The 15-20 dollar ph pens work great for measuring liquids. Have a bottle of reference to check it once a month and it should last, at 15 bucks each they are cheap to replace when it goes bad. Proper care and storage is key to any ph meter no matter the cost.
The 15 dollar probe you got is a basic one, did the blue lab pen not use a scientific grade ph probe? You will see a difference vs a basic and a scientific grade one.