PC grow box ?

I'm new to growing and I was thinking of buying a pc grow box and there are 2 that i was thinking of choosing beetween.. If you guys could check out these links and give me an opinion on which one would have a better yield i would appreciate it..

Secret Herb PC Grow Case - w/ 2X Plant Odor Control! - (eBay.ca item 230261920205 end time 20-Jun-08 15:19:18 EDT)

Hydroponics Grow Box Cabinet Light System! PC Planter ! - (eBay.ca item 290237896717 end time 20-Jun-08 19:43:00 EDT)

the second costs 2x as much and seems to do the same thing .. it is available cheaper on sunlightsheds.com, but still costs allot more than the homemade one on ebay..

I would go for the CFL one, if you really want to add hydroponics do it yourself, hella lot cheaper then the black one, and the sensors is pretty cool.