Overwatered? Will they recover or should I toss them?

Pretty sure they’re overwatered, just need to know if it’s worth continuing with them or not.

The plants in question are Cream Caramel Autoflowers on day 30 since planting the germinated seed.
The growing medium is soil, and not the best quality, mixed with perlite 70:30.
I started them on an 18/6 light schedule and moved it to 24/0 at around day 20.
The temperature has been 22-25 degrees Celsius and 50-55% RH. Before I changed the light schedule to 24/0 the temp was dropping to 16 degrees at night and peaking 80% RH at times, so I decided to just go 24/0.
I have them elevated on plant feet sitting in saucers and I remove all water as soon as it stops.
The lights have been sitting between 18-24” from the soil, and I was using at the time one Mars Hydro TS-600 per plant, in a 120cm x 60cm x 120cm tent. Now I’ve rearranged the grow tent to distribute the light among all 4 plants. (2x Cream Caramel, 2x Northern Lights)

I’ve been giving them far too much water from the start, watering to run off every time, even saturating the entire soil thoroughly to run off just before I planted the seeds. (So stupid, I know. I’m a noob.) I would water every 2-3 days, give or take. I wasn’t feeding them any nutrients.

They looked reasonably perky and healthy not even a week ago, and have slowly curled more and more. They’ve also gotten very light green coloured, they were previously a nice rich dark green.
One is far worse off than the other, but both still smell pretty strongly and have shown sex signs, and lots of little white hairs.

I watered them last 24 hours ago before I came to the conclusion that I likely chronically overwatered, and am waiting for the soil to dry out completely before I decide what to do with them, hoping that they bounce back.

I’ve got the 2 northern lights autos growing in 100% coco, they’re on day 16 and are thriving at this stage. They even look more happy than the cream caramels did at their stage. I’ve been feeding them half strength a+b nutes + half strength cal mag every couple of days when I water, making sure some run off comes out, and they seem to be doing great. I bought an EC/PPM meter today, I’ve just gotta figure out what to do with it lol. All I know is I need it.

Its disappointing I went with soil, I did it because I thought growing in coco would be more difficult with the whole having to feed nutrients every watering. It turns out to not be that difficult, and coco seems to be good for an overwatering type like myself. Hopefully I go okay with the coco because after this experience between the moisture and the fungus gnat infestation, I’m not using soil again for a while if I can..

I Just want to know if it’s worth continuing, if they’ll recover or not, if they’ll go on to produce bud, and anything else I’ve done wrong please let me know.

Your help is greatly appreciated!!
 

Attachments

bam0813

Well-Known Member
That plant looks small enough to slide out and check the condition of roots. If they look ok then let it dry and see what happens imo
 

curious2garden

Well-Known Mod
Staff member
Pretty sure they’re overwatered, just need to know if it’s worth continuing with them or not.

The plants in question are Cream Caramel Autoflowers on day 30 since planting the germinated seed.
The growing medium is soil, and not the best quality, mixed with perlite 70:30.
I started them on an 18/6 light schedule and moved it to 24/0 at around day 20.
The temperature has been 22-25 degrees Celsius and 50-55% RH. Before I changed the light schedule to 24/0 the temp was dropping to 16 degrees at night and peaking 80% RH at times, so I decided to just go 24/0.
I have them elevated on plant feet sitting in saucers and I remove all water as soon as it stops.
The lights have been sitting between 18-24” from the soil, and I was using at the time one Mars Hydro TS-600 per plant, in a 120cm x 60cm x 120cm tent. Now I’ve rearranged the grow tent to distribute the light among all 4 plants. (2x Cream Caramel, 2x Northern Lights)

I’ve been giving them far too much water from the start, watering to run off every time, even saturating the entire soil thoroughly to run off just before I planted the seeds. (So stupid, I know. I’m a noob.) I would water every 2-3 days, give or take. I wasn’t feeding them any nutrients.

They looked reasonably perky and healthy not even a week ago, and have slowly curled more and more. They’ve also gotten very light green coloured, they were previously a nice rich dark green.
One is far worse off than the other, but both still smell pretty strongly and have shown sex signs, and lots of little white hairs.

I watered them last 24 hours ago before I came to the conclusion that I likely chronically overwatered, and am waiting for the soil to dry out completely before I decide what to do with them, hoping that they bounce back.

I’ve got the 2 northern lights autos growing in 100% coco, they’re on day 16 and are thriving at this stage. They even look more happy than the cream caramels did at their stage. I’ve been feeding them half strength a+b nutes + half strength cal mag every couple of days when I water, making sure some run off comes out, and they seem to be doing great. I bought an EC/PPM meter today, I’ve just gotta figure out what to do with it lol. All I know is I need it.

Its disappointing I went with soil, I did it because I thought growing in coco would be more difficult with the whole having to feed nutrients every watering. It turns out to not be that difficult, and coco seems to be good for an overwatering type like myself. Hopefully I go okay with the coco because after this experience between the moisture and the fungus gnat infestation, I’m not using soil again for a while if I can..

I Just want to know if it’s worth continuing, if they’ll recover or not, if they’ll go on to produce bud, and anything else I’ve done wrong please let me know.

Your help is greatly appreciated!!
You could transplant them to coco now if you wish. You have nutrients and an EC meter. You need a pH meter. I think some people are just better in hydro. I've killed tons of plants in soil but hydro I can run. But if you can stop watering them enough so they dry out and then feed them appropriately I'm guessing you could finish in soil. Best of luck.
 

Hieronymus

Well-Known Member
Watering is like I never really know what I'm doing and hope for the best. I haven't over watered and only had one plant go droopy from lack of H2O but somehow it's working. Try the lift the pot method, it's worked for me.
 
Watering is like I never really know what I'm doing and hope for the best. I haven't over watered and only had one plant go droopy from lack of H2O but somehow it's working. Try the lift the pot method, it's worked for me.
I’ve tried it, it seems a lot easier to do with coco because the difference in weight. between wet coco and dry seems to be huge. I need to get more familiar with the weight of my soil pots.

One of them has made a full recovery it seems, the other actually looks worse today. They’re both smelling even stronger today and new growth is appearing it just seems really stunted on the worse off plant. Here they both are now:
 

Attachments

Herb & Suds

Well-Known Member
I’ve tried it, it seems a lot easier to do with coco because the difference in weight. between wet coco and dry seems to be huge. I need to get more familiar with the weight of my soil pots.

One of them has made a full recovery it seems, the other actually looks worse today. They’re both smelling even stronger today and new growth is appearing it just seems really stunted on the worse off plant. Here they both are now:
Coco is supposed to remain moist like hydro
 
My bad, yeah. I only felt the pot before I watered at the start and now that it’s all saturated and it’s a huge difference in weight. I could pick it up with 2 fingers before now I need to bend my knees lol.
 
Pretty sure they’re overwatered, just need to know if it’s worth continuing with them or not.

The plants in question are Cream Caramel Autoflowers on day 30 since planting the germinated seed.
The growing medium is soil, and not the best quality, mixed with perlite 70:30.
I started them on an 18/6 light schedule and moved it to 24/0 at around day 20.
The temperature has been 22-25 degrees Celsius and 50-55% RH. Before I changed the light schedule to 24/0 the temp was dropping to 16 degrees at night and peaking 80% RH at times, so I decided to just go 24/0.
I have them elevated on plant feet sitting in saucers and I remove all water as soon as it stops.
The lights have been sitting between 18-24” from the soil, and I was using at the time one Mars Hydro TS-600 per plant, in a 120cm x 60cm x 120cm tent. Now I’ve rearranged the grow tent to distribute the light among all 4 plants. (2x Cream Caramel, 2x Northern Lights)

I’ve been giving them far too much water from the start, watering to run off every time, even saturating the entire soil thoroughly to run off just before I planted the seeds. (So stupid, I know. I’m a noob.) I would water every 2-3 days, give or take. I wasn’t feeding them any nutrients.

They looked reasonably perky and healthy not even a week ago, and have slowly curled more and more. They’ve also gotten very light green coloured, they were previously a nice rich dark green.
One is far worse off than the other, but both still smell pretty strongly and have shown sex signs, and lots of little white hairs.

I watered them last 24 hours ago before I came to the conclusion that I likely chronically overwatered, and am waiting for the soil to dry out completely before I decide what to do with them, hoping that they bounce back.

I’ve got the 2 northern lights autos growing in 100% coco, they’re on day 16 and are thriving at this stage. They even look more happy than the cream caramels did at their stage. I’ve been feeding them half strength a+b nutes + half strength cal mag every couple of days when I water, making sure some run off comes out, and they seem to be doing great. I bought an EC/PPM meter today, I’ve just gotta figure out what to do with it lol. All I know is I need it.

Its disappointing I went with soil, I did it because I thought growing in coco would be more difficult with the whole having to feed nutrients every watering. It turns out to not be that difficult, and coco seems to be good for an overwatering type like myself. Hopefully I go okay with the coco because after this experience between the moisture and the fungus gnat infestation, I’m not using soil again for a while if I can..

I Just want to know if it’s worth continuing, if they’ll recover or not, if they’ll go on to produce bud, and anything else I’ve done wrong please let me know.

Your help is greatly appreciated!!
Looks like they recovered ok for now. Let them dry out completely then gave them 1.5L of water which gave them 50-100ml of runoff now they’re drying out again and look good.
Thought I would post the after pics in case anyone sees this in the future and has a similar problem
 

Attachments

Top