Non organic ferts affect on organic medium

thecannacove

Well-Known Member
Although this could be put in organic forum I thought it was probably a "newbie as hell" question. In fact, it's one I feel pretty stupid for asking. However I don't care much about ego lol.

So on with the question/background.

In my current grow I have two Holland's Hope, that although grew fantastic during veg, fizzled out in flower. All other plants have done fairly well throughout the grow, but not these two notoriously decent yielders..

However, I think I know why. All plants started in solo cups, they were transferred into #3 pots at about 3 weeks old. The pots had tga super soil on bottom 1/3, and regular tga organic for the top 2/3. They stayed in these pots for longer than I expected and became pot bound. (I didn't have needed equipment or space for flowering right away so they vegged for about 3 months).

When I transplanted to #5 pots for flower I did put some super soil (bottom 1/4 of pot). However, since the #3 pots I had were not AS narrow as the #5 it created an interesting challenge to prevent air gaps in soil. As a result, all plants likely have somewhat of an air gap between the super soil I put in the bottom of the new containers and their existing root mass.

Previously I thought the gap was the problem with the lack of vigor in my two HH plants, but now I think it may not be the problem itself but it may be causing the roots to not explore the new super soil. So the problem would be lack of bloom essential nutes caused BY the air gap. I came to this conclusion with the logic that these 2 plants had probably the best veg growth of the 11 plants i started with (now 9 since i threw 2 out). Which makes me believe they used most of what the original super soil had to offer them and now, the roots aren't migrating into the new super soil (hypothesis not fact).

But, one might ask why are just these two stunted and not all plants? Well the Hollands hope are two that had best veg growth like I mentioned, the G13 and ice plants (highest yielders currently) are smaller in stature and may not have used all of the nutrients from their original super soil.. s do they still have some "fuel in the tank" so to speak.

With that info in mind I made a hasty decision to buy some jacks classic bloom nutrients. In retrospect I'm pretty sure I should have made some organic teas instead of using synthetic fertilizers. Although I haven't caused any apparent damage (and I have actually started to see some improvement in rather limited time), I'm concerned/curious if others use syn. ferts in organic soils.. Seems kind of counter intuitive to me and I really feel kind of dumb for choosing what I did.

Correct me if I'm wrong but I don't believe it will hurt my girls, it just makes the formerly organic growing medium no longer organic...? Kinda like, might as well use a soiless mix in the future if I plan to use the jacks classic in next grow. Am I correct here?

Edit: I guess I should well.. point out the question(s) I'm seeking advice for since my post here turned into a novella, lol..

1) is my logic regarding the super soil being "used up" sound?

2) does using syn. fertilizers cause potential harm to the plants?

3) if I plan to continue to grow with the jacks classic, should I reevaluate the growing medium I choose?
 

jointed

Well-Known Member
Using salts won't hurt the organic soil Canna, the only things it will do is kill off some of the herd so to speak. There are so many of them though that their is no way your going to get rid of them all and they multiply very quickly. The salts will be available quickly as they do not have to pass through the gut of the micro beasties to be available to the plant. How many gallons of soil was in your pots ( does # = gal )

http://forums2.gardenweb.com/forums/load/contain/msg0316064615891.html?14


Check out this link. Especially the fertilizing container plants at the bottom of the op's post....J
 

jointed

Well-Known Member
I know I didn't answer your ?'s the way you had probably hoped, but I really don't know that much about organic. I want to use the mix with pine bark fines, peat moss, and perlite, because it reduces compaction and gives me total control over what my plants get and when they get it. Also I don;t believe in the use of high p bloom foods for flowering as the flowering response is a hormonal thing which I don't feel has anything to do with the food it's being fed. Anyway that's my take on it and what I'm going to do. I'll save the compost and organics for the garden. I hope this has helped you Canna...Enjoy the read my friend....J
 

jointed

Well-Known Member
I plan on using Dyna Gro foliage pro..9-3-6 the whole way through flower, I have used Jack's Classic 20-20-20 with Root's soil and had good luck with that too...J
 

thecannacove

Well-Known Member
I know I didn't answer your ?'s the way you had probably hoped, but I really don't know that much about organic.
Holy crap FUCK, quite the contrary my friend. Sorry for the sudden quiet spell but i was reading that thread for a while lol, and then the fert thread you recommended that was linked within. Absolutely the best best best answer I've had to any question I've posted to the forum to date. This guy is spot on. Very articulate yet can explain in layman's terms.
I plan on using Dyna Gro foliage pro..9-3-6 the whole way through flower, I have used Jack's Classic 20-20-20 with Root's soil and had good luck with that too...J
Before reading this post and simply reading the water retention post and fert post you supplied I was already thinking this very same thing (stick with the 3:1:2 ratio start to finish)
Did I blow it up enough for ya...LOL
You sure did.. thank you!

Lastly, you'd definitely get rep+ on this if RIU would let me, but i must spread the love. Don't worry, I won't forget it!
 

Cascadian

Well-Known Member
Thanks for that link jointed, tons of great info there...

Hey canna, just wanted to give my opinion I think there isn't any problem supplementing organic supersoil with synthetic nutes.

In my opinion supersoil with a good dose of perlite is the easiest medium to grow in and gives great consistent results. No need to change the medium as long as the dose of synthetic nutes is moderate and you use plain water every other watering.

I will definitely be looking into adding pine bark fines to the supersoil... thanks again J...
 

thecannacove

Well-Known Member
Thanks for that link jointed, tons of great info there...

Hey canna, just wanted to give my opinion I think there isn't any problem supplementing organic supersoil with synthetic nutes.

In my opinion supersoil with a good dose of perlite is the easiest medium to grow in and gives great consistent results. No need to change the medium as long as the dose of synthetic nutes is moderate and you use plain water every other watering.

I will definitely be looking into adding pine bark fines to the supersoil... thanks again J...
What do you think of using fine bark fines + s. peat as the base of a super soil?
 

Cascadian

Well-Known Member
I am thinking of using it as an amendment, not as the base soil. Pine bark fines have a very low PH and could cause problems if enough dolomite lime is not added to the supersoil. Didn't research peat, but I know people have trouble germinating in the pellets so probably the same issue...

If I add some it will be at about a 1 part pine bark fines to 2 parts base soil (using Edna's Best Organic on this round). And, I will be adding a little extra dolomite lime to counter act the low PH of the Pine Bark Fines. Trying to call around and find some now as I haven't transplanted into the supersoil yet for this grow (it is an "experimental" grow this round)... I think it would be interesting to add the Fines and see what difference if any there is.
 

jointed

Well-Known Member
http://forums2.gardenweb.com/forums/load/contain/msg041917144346.html

This might help ya Canna, I am going to the local landscape supply co's when winter loses it's icy grip here in mich. There is a bonsai club here that members of go to landscape supply co's and sift pbf's to get the required 3/8" size to use in their pot's. That way they only pay for what they sift instead of a whole truckload. Me, I want a load of it as I want to break up the garden soil to help prevent the compaction issues due to the soil being worn out so to speak...J
 

thecannacove

Well-Known Member
http://forums2.gardenweb.com/forums/load/contain/msg041917144346.html

This might help ya Canna, I am going to the local landscape supply co's when winter loses it's icy grip here in mich. There is a bonsai club here that members of go to landscape supply co's and sift pbf's to get the required 3/8" size to use in their pot's. That way they only pay for what they sift instead of a whole truckload. Me, I want a load of it as I want to break up the garden soil to help prevent the compaction issues due to the soil being worn out so to speak...J
I grabbed some from Wal-Mart today. It's actually pretty decent stuff, I'll take some pictures tonight maybe
 

Dr.J20

Well-Known Member
Correct me if I'm wrong but I don't believe it will hurt my girls, it just makes the formerly organic growing medium no longer organic...? Kinda like, might as well use a soiless mix in the future if I plan to use the jacks classic in next grow. Am I correct here?

Edit: I guess I should well.. point out the question(s) I'm seeking advice for since my post here turned into a novella, lol..

1) is my logic regarding the super soil being "used up" sound? sure it's sound, ss grows are usually flowered in 7 gal pots to take a girl through to harvest so a smaller pot should be prepared to amend.
2) does using syn. fertilizers cause potential harm to the plants?Debatable, no? organic purists will say yes, and you may be harming yourself and anyone who uses your medicine; technically, absolutely not. plants have been grown with synthetic fertilizers because they get you from seed to harvest successfully. Now, organic produce is packed with more nutrients and flavor, and is produced sustainably with positive, rather than negative impact on the earth, but that's not really a direct response to your question.
3) if I plan to continue to grow with the jacks classic, should I reevaluate the growing medium I choose?This is actually more of your preference. If you want to recycle the soil you can, if you want to switch to a soilless medium you can do that too. If you WANT to go organic, you can't really disregard the negative effect synthetics have on your soil because that's part of the soil-food-web. You don't have a web without 'em. They're what break down the organic materials in your organic soil and feed them to the plants. Another side benefit of organics is easy soil recycling so you save money in the long run, rather than mixing up bunches of soilless mix that gets slammed with salt buildups. just my 2 cents though
answers in bold.
be easy,
:peace:
 

thecannacove

Well-Known Member
answers in bold.
be easy,
:peace:
Dr J. Thanks for the advice :) I think what I was really conflicted about is synthetic fertilizers potential harm to the medium more than the plant itself. My post was long and in the end confusing to even myself. Nonetheless, it yielded great encouraging answers. Thank you everyone
 

jointed

Well-Known Member
Canna answer #3 can be or doesn't have to be an issue. It all depends on your regimine, some prefer feed, water, water, feed and so on. I myself tend to feel that one should feed constantly with a very mild dose every time. I feel this helps to avoid the feeding deficiencies that are all to often misdiagnosed with nutrient deficiencies. IOW if you feed your plant heavily and then water it 2-3 times consecutively your plant can exibit issues that are directly attributed to your feeding style. It's a boom, bust cycle thing...I hope I didn't confuse you bro...J
 

jointed

Well-Known Member
I was referring to the salt build-up issue. And another thing it all depends on what media you choose as to how much damage it does to the environment, pine bark fines, perlite, and peat moss are the least of our problems, compared to what some companies are dumping into our rivers and landfills....J
 

thecannacove

Well-Known Member
Canna answer #3 can be or doesn't have to be an issue. It all depends on your regimine, some prefer feed, water, water, feed and so on. I myself tend to feel that one should feed constantly with a very mild dose every time. I feel this helps to avoid the feeding deficiencies that are all to often misdiagnosed with nutrient deficiencies. IOW if you feed your plant heavily and then water it 2-3 times consecutively your plant can exibit issues that are directly attributed to your feeding style. It's a boom, bust cycle thing...I hope I didn't confuse you bro...J
Nope I'm trackin. Feeding in smaller doses every watering makes way more sense to me than a larger dose every other watering. Al agrees with this feeding schedule as well :)
 

thecannacove

Well-Known Member
I was referring to the salt build-up issue. And another thing it all depends on what media you choose as to how much damage it does to the environment, pine bark fines, perlite, and peat moss are the least of our problems, compared to what some companies are dumping into our rivers and landfills....J
Pbf can also last far longer than your average compost as well
 
Top