Need Help Deciding!

KolaBear

New Member
Ok guys I am looking to start a grow indoors and need some help deciding on the setup. Originally I was sold on the idea of a 4x8 tent with 2 - 1000w HPS.

My goal is to yield 2 pounds every cycle ( 8 - 10 weeks )

I have now come across PLATINUM LED lights. Due to the significant decrease in energy usage, heat, and the use of an AC. I think I am convinced to go with the Led setup. Since its a lot more money for initial setup I might have to start with a 4x4 area and work up to a 4x8 depending on what you guys think I can yield in half that size?

Here are some options I priced out.

4x4 Tent
P300 LED X 2 = $738.00

4x4 Tent
P450 LED X 2 = $1000.00

8x4 Tent
P300 x 4 = $1,404.00 ( discount for buying more )

8x4 Tent
P450 x 4 = $1,896.00 ( discount for buying more )

Obviously the p300s are a cheaper option but are those lights going to have enough wattage and coverage? Maybe I am wrong for trying to use these light sizes? But from what I have read people are using more smaller panels to cover area instead of less big ones.

Also.. How many plants would you recommend I put in those areas? Keeping in mine I would like to yield 2 pounds in the 8x4.
 

jijiandfarmgang

Well-Known Member
How about getting a 5x5 tent with 1 1000 watt hps. You won't hit your goal first time around but it is obtainable.

People don't really pump out potatoes with leds. Sure there is always the exception for the rule, but if you don't believe me check out the led forum.

- Jiji
 

deadgro

Well-Known Member
How about getting a 5x5 tent with 1 1000 watt hps. You won't hit your goal first time around but it is obtainable.

People don't really pump out potatoes with leds. Sure there is always the exception for the rule, but if you don't believe me check out the led forum.

- Jiji
I agree no one is growing potatoes. But we do grow big, juicy cannabis buds the same size or bigger than ancient sodium bulbs.
 

jijiandfarmgang

Well-Known Member
I agree no one is growing potatoes. But we do grow big, juicy cannabis buds the same size or bigger than ancient sodium bulbs.
Must be a well kept secret then. I've never seen it. Maybe you should tell all the commercial grow ops about leds because apparently they don't know either.

- Jiji

Edit - There's no doubt leds can grow healthy plants. If your growing in a cab or closet or hobby, this is a good thing. If your growing for yields, your looking in the wrong area.
 
Last edited:

deadgro

Well-Known Member
Must be a well kept secret then. I've never seen it. Maybe you should tell all the commercial grow ops about leds because apparently they don't know either.

- Jiji

Edit - There's no doubt leds can grow healthy plants. If your growing in a cab or closet or hobby, this is a good thing. If your growing for yields, your looking in the wrong area.
Commercial grow ops exist to make money, everything else is secondary. Not a strong argument, ma'am.

I'll end on that. The OP is obviously interested in LED. I'm not going to argue and continue helping you shit on his thread.
 

KolaBear

New Member
Hey guys I get it.. The old HPS vs LED argument always arises.. Thanks for your feedback. Yes I can go buy a cheap HPS setup but I don't want to battle heat issues or a higher electric bill if I don't have to? Sure it will cost more money up front and I'm ok with that because I know it will pay it self off. The lower usage bill alone makes me feel easier about growing in my house.
 

KolaBear

New Member
That being said I'm really looking for someone with experience with LEDs to tell me how many panels I will need ( without over kill )
 

fandango

Well-Known Member
We run 250w LED lights...2 lights cover 3x6 and are held about 12" above the plants which are grown in 9" square pots.
6 plants under each light.Veg only here.Very slow growth compared to the Mh lighting.
I imagine if I turned the 6 plants to flower under the LED light I would pull about 60 grams per run.
 

Thom Franklin

New Member
Hey Kola,

TL : DR - LEDS = Look out for MCOBs to hit the scene soon. Be damn careful you know who your supplier is, and who your OEM is. Commercial and LED = relighting with ROI as low as 255/mth at 50-60k investment, try passing that on anyone, recreational marijuana (WA/OR/CO) will see LED, Induction, and lec with new interest, you know soon.

That old argument exists for a reason. Eastablishment relies on a continued interaction with the customer. All the new tech provides the promise of less replacement and less continued maintenance, which is terrifying if the success of your business relies on people continually having to replace and fix their technology. This is the exact way Microsoft thinks about how to create an operating system and the same way your local bulb supplier operates. The store gets to sell you one hood, which is good till you break it, everything else they sell you is a guessing game of lifetime and warranty(ballasts, bulbs, nutes). Electronics fail and if you want to make money in them, you either sell tons of breakable replaceable shit, or a few really good items.

This should not be the same case with LEDs which offer longer lifespans and less finicky tech platforms than a filament, but choose your supplier carefully as many are simply third party distributors who know nothing about the tech or their product. Cidly.com (wholesaler, call for prices and availability) manufactures a number of the popular led enclosures out there, namely the apollo series which I have seen floating around discussions in several forums. Igrow (induction) for example is just rebranding another company's lights to some degree and has already been copied a half dozen ways in china. The company Igrow purchase's from sells 500w induction grow lights for half the cost($500 vs 1200) and does not waste half as much time with claims and psudo science. This is a common practice in business, DNA lighting does it with lots of folks tech.

Personal manufacturer experience: In the process of researching LED lighting, I contacted Supergrowled.com for a quote on lights for a 800 sq ft space back before Christmas. He asked for clear drawings of the space when he returned from the holidays(after new years); I provided them a few days later and another two weeks go by before Bob returned from another vacation to tell me he can get it done in a few days. Welp still no word, not encouraging, and I was looking to get a quote for 50 of the damn things. I have since developed a general tool for calculating light needs on my own. They also base all their claims from 2012, so you know update some crap and get back to us, by today's standards of shelf life that shit is ancient history. (I started by being excited about these guys, see my first post)

Manufacturer claims in the days of the internet: Chinese or Canadian you decide!

Here is the manufacturer of the spiders:
http://twilightgroup.manufacturer.globalsources.com/si/6008843450522/pdtl/LED-grow/1112491606/COB-LED-grow-light.htm

here is a retailer:
http://www.ledcanada.com/spider-4x-mcob-led-growlight.html

maybe they are not the same, though that spider design has me seeing double.

Shit this does not seem to have helped. welcome to my boat. LED is real and works(legit studies, real vegetable farms), commercial ops don't use them because switching is cost prohibitive 30k out the door for year one gavita de 1000w setup at 40 lights, vs 40-50k year one for equivalent LEDs. I am doing the research, these are rough numbers, but bulbs for Traditional lighting is only 5.7k a year at this scale. How as a business person do you justify replacing your entire system at 40-50k vs continuing to maintain at 5-15k a year with current tech, ROI for relighting being as little as 250/mth off the power bill. not to mention being over equipped with HVAC, etc. after relighting was complete.

The large commercial LED ops won't be here posting till folks like myself are out of the planning phase and deploying with the expansion of recreational weed in WA/OR/CO (you know cause I can talk about my job like a job). I also have to believe that a dealer with working lights will be blowing smoke up our asses long before a grower who is getting results on this scale will start shouting from the mountain tops that LED is the way to go. LED at scale on initial startup (year one figures) should help growers operating margins considerably. Which reminds me, I have calculations to do on power consumption.

I at least hope this all covered some gaps in education, researching this all is tedious as it is a new frontier.

~Thom
 

Thom Franklin

New Member
YW! Been absorbing nothing but numbers on this crap and it helped me organize and proof a bunch of stuff for a business plan. So thank you as well.
 
Top