led vs hps

puffenuff · Sep 30, 2011

I kiss my wallet all the time. I have excellent coversations with my banker and financial advisors. I'd say my money and my mouth are on the same page.

del66666 · Sep 30, 2011

hps 12-12 from seed............

puffenuff · Sep 30, 2011

Cute plants. You did a great job del.

fssalaska · Sep 30, 2011

LED The big scam ! You can grow with them but they suck ass for budding, and yes I have bought and used them. LED lights for home lighting is awesome also great for street lighting but for growing bullshit.

https://www.rollitup.org/indoor-growing/405548-test-grow-mh-sunshine-90w.html#post5257265

del66666 · Sep 30, 2011

puffenuff said:
Cute plants. You did a great job del.

cheers mate ...... i wont show you the ones that went wrong.......i call them my little freaks

del66666 · Sep 30, 2011

fssalaska said:
LED The big scam ! You can grow with them but they suck ass for budding, and yes I have bought and used them. LED lights for home lighting is awesome also great for street lighting but for growing bullshit.

https://www.rollitup.org/indoor-growing/405548-test-grow-mh-sunshine-90w.html#post5257265"]https://www.rollitup.org/indoor-growing/405548-test-grow-mh-sunshine-90w.html#post5257265[/COLOR]

have you seen irishboys led grows....pretty good

fssalaska · Sep 30, 2011

some people have luck with them I guess, I'm dam sure not one of them.

https://www.rollitup.org/indoor-growing/405548-test-grow-mh-sunshine-90w.html#post5257265

puffenuff · Sep 30, 2011

del66666 said:
cheers mate ...... i wont show you the ones that went wrong.......i call them my little freaks

We all have some children we're ashamed of...no hard feelings about the silly back and forth banter. I just chopped my latest..will try to upload some nug shots later today...not to compare against yours but to show some quality led nugs.

peruviankush · Sep 30, 2011

I haven't tried either but basically theres a few key advantages/disadvantages

LED: Needs more area, footprintwise. However vertically it can be slimmer.
HPS: Gives off more heat. If you go with a pro grow LED light box, it should have a fan built in though.
LED: Will end up more expensive to setup but be cheaper on your electric bill in the long run.
LED: Will be safer and last longer.
LED: Shouldn't change color over time as HPS can.

IMO LED is the way to go, and there are some good looking units online. It's expensive but the footprint makes it really practical in some setups. You probably wouldn't need much else besides that for the given area.

HPS takes up space and its hot. It's strong but IMO can't cover the same area as equally as an LED array.

And I've never tried it, but this one looks bad-ass: GrowStealth.

puffenuff · Sep 30, 2011

fssalaska said:
some people have luck with them I guess, I'm dam sure not one of them.

Im just guessing because ive never used those lights you mentioned, but it may have been the lights you chose and not the fault of leds in general. Not all leds are created equal. Gotta spend money to make money.

del66666 · Sep 30, 2011

puffenuff said:
We all have some children we're ashamed of...no hard feelings about the silly back and forth banter. I just chopped my latest..will try to upload some nug shots later today...not to compare against yours but to show some quality led nugs.

cool mate..of course no hard feelings mate......not after a drama just messing..

fssalaska · Sep 30, 2011

peruviankush said:
I haven't tried either but basically theres a few key advantages/disadvantages

LED: Needs more area, footprintwise. However vertically it can be slimmer.
HPS: Gives off more heat. If you go with a pro grow LED light box, it should have a fan built in though.
LED: Will end up more expensive to setup but be cheaper on your electric bill in the long run.
LED: Will be safer and last longer.
LED: Shouldn't change color over time as HPS can.

IMO LED is the way to go, and there are some good looking units online. It's expensive but the footprint makes it really practical in some setups. You probably wouldn't need much else besides that for the given area.

HPS takes up space and its hot. It's strong but IMO can't cover the same area as equally as an LED array.

Leds, Do get weaker over time a fact.

del66666 · Sep 30, 2011

peruviankush said:
I haven't tried either but basically theres a few key advantages/disadvantages

LED: Needs more area, footprintwise. However vertically it can be slimmer.
HPS: Gives off more heat. If you go with a pro grow LED light box, it should have a fan built in though.
LED: Will end up more expensive to setup but be cheaper on your electric bill in the long run.
LED: Will be safer and last longer.
LED: Shouldn't change color over time as HPS can.

IMO LED is the way to go, and there are some good looking units online. It's expensive but the footprint makes it really practical in some setups. You probably wouldn't need much else besides that for the given area.

HPS takes up space and its hot. It's strong but IMO can't cover the same area as equally as an LED array.

And I've never tried it, but this one looks bad-ass: GrowStealth.

hps do take up space but not that much...i have a wooden grow cab 1mx1.2mx1.4 hi with a 400 and 600 hps in there no probs with heat

del66666 · Sep 30, 2011

puffenuff said:
Im just guessing because ive never used those lights you mentioned, but it may have been the lights you chose and not the fault of leds in general. Not all leds are created equal. Gotta spend money to make money.

thats the trouble.....to many dodge leds at mo......maybe in time things will change

fssalaska · Sep 30, 2011

puffenuff said:
Im just guessing because ive never used those lights you mentioned, but it may have been the lights you chose and not the fault of leds in general. Not all leds are created equal. Gotta spend money to make money.

I had one of the 3 watt blackstars 240 watt its one of the best from what the mindless youtubers say.
I have a hard time talking to someone that has no clue of what I'm talking about , buy some pay the money 1200 bucks and see the shit resolts for yourself then lets talk.

puffenuff · Sep 30, 2011

Im talking to you now. I have purchased over a thousand dollars worth of leds, and made my money back on the first harvest. I have not experienced any shit results. You have most likely because you bought shitty lights and/or didn't adjust your growing techniques.

fssalaska · Sep 30, 2011

puffenuff said:
Im talking to you now. I have purchased over a thousand dollars worth of leds, and made my money back on the first harvest. I have not experienced any shit results. You have most likely because you bought shitty lights and/or didn't adjust your growing techniques.

Your a cute little butt nugget !

Oh shit Oh dear.. You are the man !

fssalaska · Sep 30, 2011

puffenuff said:
Im just guessing because ive never used those lights you mentioned, but it may have been the lights you chose and not the fault of leds in general. Not all leds are created equal. Gotta spend money to make money.

^ have not used those lights < your words , My words > STFU if you don't no what I'm talking about.

puffenuff · Sep 30, 2011

fssalaska said:
^ have not used those lights < your words , My words > STFU if you don't no what I'm talking about.

The way I see it is you don't like LEDs because you had a bad experience with poor quality lights and probably had high hopes for them; however, don't get all butthurt because I told you your lights aren't good which I assumed you'd agree with given your previous statements on LEDs and your experience. I'll stop talking to you now, but not because you told me to "STFU" but because I don't like your attitude. Happy growing man, try not to be so rude to people next time.

fssalaska · Sep 30, 2011

puffenuff said:
The way I see it is you don't like LEDs because you had a bad experience with poor quality lights and probably had high hopes for them; however, don't get all butthurt because I told you your lights aren't good which I assumed you'd agree with given your previous statements on LEDs and your experience. I'll stop talking to you now, but not because you told me to "STFU" but because I don't like your attitude. Happy growing man, try not to be so rude to people next time.

not being rude to people, just you.

led vs hps

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Attachments

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member