https://growershouse.com/blog/cmh-315w-lamp-comparison-test-data-review/
Phillips 3100k beats other bulbs by 8% average PAR
Ushio has 1% higher uv but is 10% lower in par.
In my side by sides the Phillips lamp yields as much as 30% less than my 600 Hortilux super hps. And the 600 hps pot was chosen as more potent almost every time in our blind testing.
Wattage is still king. Don’t believe the hype.
I had posted last year that the cmh grew more potent pot but we removed the cmh from the room and potency and frost were as high or higher each clone run.
The benefits of the 315 over the hps are it helps keep plants shorter and more compact at the expense of somewhat leafier buds. And it brings out more fall colors and shortens ripening up to a week on some strains. And it keeps plants greener. It also is a low watt easy to use bulb. Too low watt for best results as a single flowering lamp in my opinion.
The 315 footprint for flowering is also smaller than even a 400 hps at 2.5’ x 2.5’. That is with the ss open vertical reflector made specifically for the bulb at 18”.
The best buds were grown with both lamps. The 315 cmh is a fantastic supplemental lamp to complete a great flowering spectrum with hps.