Good question
I guess I felt that the vertical reflective capability of the OG would be superior to a horizontal parabolic. Is that true? But in the end you're right, it is a bit of a waste. I am torn between trying an OG reflector with a Solis Tek ballakt and Eye Hortilux HPS, and just getting another Gavita 600W all in one. I really like the Gavita light a lot, the only downside is that they only come in 240V which requires rewiring a room.
Yes the OG is much better than even a vertical parabolic I have both. I mainly run LED's But also run HPS my best results were with the OG reflector A one generation back Lumatek 1Kw balast and and a Lumatek bulb. Run at 1.2K for first two weeks. Then dimmed to 1K for two weeks Then dimmed to .75K for 2 weeks and finished the last few weeks with it Dimmed down to 600 Watts.
This seemed to simulate the summer/Fall season real well and packed on a lot of frost and a whole lot more yeild than any other light/hood/ or led combo's I have ever tried in my 30 + years at this. The lumatek is by far the longest lasting best balast I have ever run. Combining it with the OG vertical fixture is a match made in heaven. I use an 8" duct booster fan pushing the air thrrough and conical charcol filter on the inlet side of the fan.
I imagine you could run this without air cooling as it does run much cooler.
I dont have any affiliation with Lumatek but have used enough other garbage on the market ( and there is alot of it ) to say you would be very happy with that balast. they run 110v-240v and are dimmable. I see they now have a newer one out that is more shaped like a C.A.P. Next gen than the last generation that I have. I cannot speek to its quality. As for the EYE Horts they are as good or better than any I have tried. for me its a $$$ toss up. Which ever I can get Horts or Lumes bulk on Ebay the cheapest. I just got 3 of the Lumateks new for $125 They seem as good as the Horts with one upgrade. They have stiffer support For the fillament (and so less wiggle in it when it powers on with a Digi Balast) within the bulb.
Also one more thing about balasts I always buy the 1ks because they will power 1-3 400 watt bulbs or 2 600 watt bulbs or a single 1k or just 1 400 or 600 or 1000w. Last but not least please forgive my spelling and grammer. I have been told I am an idiotsavant when it comes to growing and breeding but not much good for anything else.