Jogro
Well-Known Member
You may not like the answers, but I think this has been answered already fairly definitively.It's a thread to try and get to the bottom of why seed breeders have discontinued carrying regular seeds.
Markets have their own niches. Some breeders are just "old school" and don't want to bother feminizing lines. Some buyers want only regs, and there are breeders who cater to these buyers. But what works for one breeder doesn't work for all of them. Just like there is a niche for regs, there is a niche for fems too. As a matter of practice, DNA probably sells more beans than 90% of the breeders.Many major seed breeders offer JUST regular seeds of their most sought-after strains, so obviously the business model works and is working for them.
Its funny, I heard a High Times Cup panel with DNA (I think it was Don, can't remember) and Scott from Rare Dankness talking about fems. Scott said something to the effect of "We don't offer fems", and then Don responded "We were the same way once, too. . .you say that now. . .just wait". Market pressure is a real factor here.
The ones actually in the business of making and selling beans. . .the ones who know which ones sell and which ones don't. . .all state the contrary, that demand for fem beans exceeds that for regs. With due respect, since they're the ones whose livelihoods depend on moving beans, they're probably in a better position to determine this than you are.I contend that seed breeders would sell just as many seeds if they sold them exclusively regular, and not to mention, people would be forced to buy MORE seed because not all those seeds would be female.
Sure if EVERY breeder simultaneously stopped selling fem beans, they'd end up selling just as many packs of regs, but its a highly competitive marketplace and that's just not realistic.
In terms of volumes, since regular packs are on average 50% female, and since feminized se-eds typically cost 2x the price of regs, cost per fem bean is about the same for buyers and doesn't really play into this. So sure, if breeders were moving 10-packs of regs instead of 5-packs of fems, they'll be moving twice the absolute number of beans. . .but the customer wouldn't be paying more, nor getting more, and the breeders won't be making more money. I've already explained why this cost structure actually favors breeders; they can double the "bean value" of a plant if they use reversed pollen on it (vs regular).
So instead of pining over your girlfriend who dumped you (DNA), why don't you reward the ones who stock excellent regular lines with your business? With enough buyers like you, DNA will happily revert to re-issuing regular lines, where it can. They've done it in with individual strains, and indicated that they intend to do so again. But if most buyers don't care, why should they cater to the small minority like you?Proof of this is breeders who DON'T carry feminized seed AT ALL, yet are successful and have award winning strains that everyone wants to boot.
I think there is a misunderstanding here. If the banks are out of DNA regulars, then the only real option to get them is directly from DNA in Europe, assuming they stock any. That's at least possible, if not easy or cheap.Listen, there aren't "plenty of others" who are willing to offer guaranteed DNA regular seeds of their major seed brands, or at least, anyone that I'd trust enough with my hard-earned money. . . They've lost my business if this is how they want to run their company, although I'm sure all the noobs out there growing for the first time will keep their pockets filled with business for years to come.
Anyway, there isn't much to say on this anymore, we're going in circles. Personally, I also prefer regs and tend to avoid the "fem only" breeders but even so, I wouldn't let lack of regs prevent me from growing out something in fem form I was otherwise really interested in. We've already talked about how fems aren't really a barrier to breeding.
If you still want regs from DNA, write them a nice letter explaining how you're a satisfied customer who loves their regs, and how you're sorry you feel like you need to take your business elsewhere because you can't buy them anymore. At that point the ball is in their court; either they earn your business or they don't.