Just a guess because I don't know for sure, but I feel like if you are going to try to stretch the growspace, it's the growth space, the five-by-five would probably work better it's really worked better because it's only 6" further on the spectrum all the way around. If you go to the 4 by 8, then you have your 4' foot foot breathe one way but then you're trying to stretch that light 4' the other direction or 2' each way if you put it in the middle. So, Just by reasonable deducting, and no scientific proof, my guess is the 5 by 5 would be the way to go. Unless of course you plan on buying a second light to match and in the 4 by 8 would be a perfect fit.