Hey bud,
You should detail what your process was and how long each stage took.
As it seams you have the answer to the ops question.
How long did you leave the seeds in water?
How long does it normally take as you said it took a little longer?
Then what did you do ?
Was the water tap water?
Boiled water?
Ph adjusted ?
Did you scratch the seed at all before placing in glass?
And what is a happy frog?
Haven't grown in many many years.
Thinking about popping a few seeds out my self.
I normally use a prop mat and clone box with Pete pellets or rockwool.
But my seeds are a few years on.
So curious to hear you opinion.
Cheers mate
I was just about to comment on water and soaking! Good questions!
It should be noted that many "High end" breeders are now sending out notice with their gear that they say to NOT presoak seeds as they are getting too many requests for replacements because of "drowning" seeds!
Reason why would be that some are using
distilled, boiled or water set out from taps to remove chlorine etc.!!!
These waters contain at BEST only TRACE amounts of dissolved o2 (you know, oxygen).
Seeds need to exchange o2 in the moisture/water they use to pop!
I
do scuff my older seeds and new ones that are 2-3 times bigger then average seeds. You know, matchbook/sandpaper thing!
The best solution for this problem is to add 1oz of H2o2 to 1 pint of pH adjusted to 6.5 water and
then soak in that solution. You can use as much or as little of the water as you want to soak in. NO longer then 24 hr soak (just to be safe) before moving to a media ! The idea is to not pop IN the water!
I use the paper towel method with the o2 enhanced water and have for years and years! Never had any problems! Fresh seeds go 24hrs and have popped and have perfect taps roots.
You might be careful of using a prop mat! If it goes over 10 degrees (F) from air ambient. It
could reduce success rates...I simply find a warmer place in the grow and put my container there. I have had old seeds (up to 14 years) take as long as 3-4 days to pop. The older the seed the less vigor it will have! ASAP get that "retirement aged" popped bean into a media and deliver some seedling feed, as older beans are lacking the nutrient stores they need to get them going.
Seed storage should be done in non - air permeable containment and stored in a fridge!
Oh yeah, Happy Frog is a soil by Fox Farm.