This again is a common case of misunderstanding. The levels of UVB drop according to the inverse square law just as every other light does. It also has the same limitation as the inverse square law in a confined/reflective space (note that white does not reflect UVB, so wall must be mylar to effectively use UVB.) In a confined reflective space, the light can only spread outward until reflecting off the walls. So the inverse square law is limited to the spread of your floor space. Example, if a light is 1 ft away and projects a 1 sqft footprint it will be said to be at full strength. Now if the room is 4x4 and the light is 4ft up the light will spread to the full 16 sqft, if the light is raised another 1 ft the light will not diminish in strength at all (except the tiny loss of the reflector), so it will still be 1/16th as bright as the 1 sqft, not the 1/25th that the inverse square law would lead you to believe. This is because the inverse square law is based on the assumption that you are in an unconfined space.
In the case of UVB, the light isn't absorbed by the air within 18", it just spreads to the point where 1 bulb can't keep a reptile healthy past that range because the levels will have dropped too much. Now if you lined the outside of a 18"x18"x72" box with mylar, and put the UVB bulb all the way at the top, the reptile would still be healthy 72" below because light levels would still be the same.
200w of 9.9 tanning over 32sqft puts me just a bit higher than the average UVB dose in the Hindu Kush Mountains.
The effects you see from a 400 merc vapor is most likely from UVA and deep blues. UVB light is easily blocked by more than 1 layer of glass, if you have a bulb with 2 layers of glass or use a fixture with a layer of glass, the UVB output of any HID bulb is effectively zero. The nice thing with tanning bulbs is they put out UVA, UVB, and Deep blues but nothing else.
With tanning bulbs and DIY fixtures it's so cheap you can't afford not to do it, lol. In your case it would be even a better deal, I would just buy a used tanning bed (can be found for $100 often on craigslist) and a new set of bulbs and a few 1x6 boards and mylar. I bet you could have your much larger space outfitted the same as mine for less than $400.
Not arguing = explaining my position OK?
The power and out put design of repti bulbs are set for low distance effectiveness - I called the makers years ago and had the discussion with them.....Yes the square inverse law is part of their computations... I tend to believe engineers.
Merc vapors DO Put out LARGE amounts of UVB and include quite specific FEDERALLY MANDATED WARNINGS right on the packaging! Merc vapors are intended to be on the endangered list by gov intervention! The FED is looking to possibly ban them and require the no manufacturing of them directly
for the reason of the UV emissions ! This has slipped in the last few years to a back burner from pressure from the industry. Info from engineers at GE..They state that for the purpose I proposed to use them. To where eye protection from the concentrated UV present. I was also warned that they may tend to "overexpose" the plants and kill them in short order......I experimented with that too. It did and I came to run them for short times during my lighting sched. The most pronounced effect was when run about 2/3's of the way through the on time and for no less then 10 min and no more then 20.......
Note to ponder. The plant I "cooked" to death with the UV was, well,,,,,blinding in effect......I achieved the same effects by the controlled exposure too!
However, you are correct that the
borosilicate glass used in the bulb's, does reduce UV emission (another Fed regulation as per discussion with engineers at EYE - This point even carries over to your window glass by coatings and content!). They do say that even with that in mind, you can get some from simply removing the glass sheet from your hood and using a MH bulb for your last weeks before harvest! Not a lot mind you, and less then the sun but, they state that enough to actually
make a difference!
I have to ask this as I'm kind of interested......How many watts per bulb and can you find me the running amps of one too? Like maybe meter it if you have one..
GREAT BACK AND FORTH discussion!
If you like we could take this PM.....WAIT!!!!
We better not, I'm sure this is getting attention of interested parties.....My other UV discussions did a lot!