Fire danger

valuablevariable

Well-Known Member
Anybody have any close calls with lamps being too close to material so that it charred or burned it? Not sure if i should be worrying about leaving my box alone for 7 hours while im in classes. All ive got now is CFLs but still its a thought thats constantly in the back of my mind when im out of the room.
 

northerntights

Well-Known Member
unless you tampered with the wireing or got the sockets wet CFL won't catch on fire. HPS on the other hand can get very hot but with a good ballast and good wiring and ventilation thats usually not an issue.
 

green_nobody

Well-Known Member
CFLs will heat up to about 175F, so they are still in the safe range. it is a other story with HPS and MH bulbs which get damn hot and can explode too. they have to be set up in a way to minimise fire risk. the bigger risk is really coming from multi-plugs, noob wiring and too strange breakers in a circuit. get wiring always done by a pro!
 

babygro

Well-Known Member
cfls actually get hotter then both hps and mh bulbs, but the heat is more dispersed.
Nonsense - try touching a compact fluorescent with your finger then try the same thing with a HID bulb and then tell me CFL's get hotter than HIDs.
 

babygro

Well-Known Member
cfls have a greater area to dispense the heat, think about it.
Since when has being able to touch a cfl tube with your finger and not burning it and getting it burnt if you touch a HID bulb got to do with heat dispersal?

Try it - practical experiment for you - let us know which finger gets burnt.
 

Brokenhope420

Well-Known Member
^^ exactly. HID bulbs do get much much hotter than cfls. Heat dispersal has nothing to do with what bulb gets hotter [except inside the bulb 0_o]...

what your talking about doobs, is net heat output; and still HID's would have more net heat output than cfls, and net heat output does not matter when it comes to temperature the bulb gets.

anyways I actually had the same worries, I was scared the first day I left it when I was at school [way back when I was clueless and using incandescents]... cfls are perfectly fine though, I use them, and I actually found paper laying against the lit bulb today [had been like that for 8 or so hours], and no problem.
 

green_nobody

Well-Known Member
^^ exactly. HID bulbs do get much much hotter than cfls. Heat dispersal has nothing to do with what bulb gets hotter [except inside the bulb 0_o]...

anyways I actually had the same worries, I was scared the first day I left it when I was at school [way back when I was clueless and using incandescents]... cfls are perfectly fine though, I use them, and I actually found paper laying against the lit bulb today [had been like that for 8 or so hours], and no problem.
good example with the paper, would still try it. but for sure this stunt can't be pulled with a HID bulb:twisted:
 

DoobsDay

Well-Known Member
"what your talking about doobs, is net heat output"

ty broken for not being so ignorant. it was just meant to be an innocent "beleive it or not" kinda things, not something for these peeps to jump on.
 

green_nobody

Well-Known Member
you state first that a CFL radiates more heat then a HID which is bull, sure the got a little advantage in surface to spread heat but in general a HID bulb will radiate more heat per hour then a tiny CFL! with those big envo lights it is a bit different story but a HID still heats up more then a CFL, end of the story!
 

valuablevariable

Well-Known Member
left the box on during the night while i was gone, horrible sleep imagening the place burning down. Everything turned out ok though
 

green_nobody

Well-Known Member
^^so you ran your HPS in there? did you record the themps in there somehow? would love to know how hot it was in there at peak;)
 

green_nobody

Well-Known Member
i wasn't concerned about the big envo light you running in there, they get a bit hot but not that terrible hot;) but i'm concerned about the possibility of you running the HPS in there!;)
 
Top