I've been wondering about this. I suppose when u think about it the plant is basically alive still either way. Why not just chop em. The difference is cutting off the water supply. If u leave then rooted in darkness for a few days what does the ability to drink thru the roots do for ripening of buds. Probably not much difference. Then u have boiling the roots....Lol wonders never cease.
Well cutting off the water supply isn't the main idea, I don't believe. The concept is that by depriving the plant of sunlight, it will bulk up its buds in an effort to get any possible shred of male pollen that it can. It makes sense if you think about it. Marijuana measures the amount of light it receives and responds accordingly- which is why, when you flip the lights from 18/6 to 12/12 for example, it'll switch from the vegetative phase to the flowering phase. So, by giving it numerous hours of complete darkness, you're making the plant think, "Oh shit, it must already be fall or winter because I'm not getting any sunlight and all the males will be dead soon, I should try to get as much pollen as I can quickly". At least, that's the theory- but, that's the point of this thread, to see whether that's what's actually happening or not. Personally, it makes sense to me, and I've heard a lot of people say it works. However, I think you're right to a degree, I doubt it makes a super significant difference in the quality, but really, can it hurt since you're gonna chop it down anyway?