Led and hps together

Sif1

Well-Known Member
I thought cmh bulb was good for 1 yr?
Of course that depends on just flowering using or both.
I'm about 9 to 10 months, then use the old as a spare.

On bulbs and going back to HPS 600. The best screw end one I have found is the Indoor Sun Pro. These outperformed Hortilux. I've tried everything. Have almost 25k of Leds sitting in the shed.
 

Norml56

Well-Known Member
I thought cmh bulb was good for 1 yr?
Of course that depends on just flowering using or both.
I only run mine for flowering.
according to the spec sheet
High 85% PPF maintenance at 20,000 hr. 12hrs a day 4.5 years and that's only a 15% loss. I'll replace it because the bulbs are only $70 apiece, and I just have the one light.
 

Purpfarmer

Well-Known Member
1. HPS only
-Lowest investment
-Proven technology
-Higher amount of waste heat/electricity consumption

2. HPS + CMH
-Slightly higher investment than HPS only
-With enhanced blue, full-spectrum light and small UV component gives a higher quality end product than HPS only

3. LED only
-Much lower electricity consumption (35-40%) with additional lower cooling requirement with further electricity savings.
-High investment cost (4-5times the amount of HPS only)
-Good spectrum with high blue amount yields high quality end product

4. LED + HPS
-Medium investment
-Saves 20-25% electricity with an additional lower cooling requirement
-High quality end product as we can add extra blue light with the LED

Hope this helps.
I'll do two
I'm about 9 to 10 months, then use the old as a spare.

On bulbs and going back to HPS 600. The best screw end one I have found is the Indoor Sun Pro. These outperformed Hortilux. I've tried everything. Have almost 25k of Leds sitting in the shed.
Where do you buy them because that website doesn't give you the option
 

hybridway2

Amare Shill
1. HPS only
-Lowest investment
-Proven technology
-Higher amount of waste heat/electricity consumption

2. HPS + CMH
-Slightly higher investment than HPS only
-With enhanced blue, full-spectrum light and small UV component gives a higher quality end product than HPS only

3. LED only
-Much lower electricity consumption (35-40%) with additional lower cooling requirement with further electricity savings.
-High investment cost (4-5times the amount of HPS only)
-Good spectrum with high blue amount yields high quality end product

4. LED + HPS
-Medium investment
-Saves 20-25% electricity with an additional lower cooling requirement
-High quality end product as we can add extra blue light with the LED

Hope this helps.
Or=
#5. New Led. The new leds available rn that will give you close to or better spectrum then the CMH (finally) while maintaining 2.1-2.6 umol/j. Those efficiency ratings are only measuring between 400-700nm. That provides the typical PPFD. When measuring the true spectrum you'll get a higher PBFD.
Representing the Normal par as well as what they call "The Beyond Par Region" (a term used to admit a mistake it sounds, lol!)
These New High-End (all in one true full spectrum with no need to supplement) Led fixtures are the best of both worlds I'd imagine. Still waiting on mine to arrive.
There's a few out there that know of:
1) Amare Bar-6 LUV. Canna-Spec + 385nm.
Canna-Spec spectrum includes x2 whites, 470, 630, 660 + 740nm to create a broad Horticultural spectrum.
On dual remote driver channels with dimmers allowing spectral blending & dimming between veg + flower modes.
-DIodes: 301H + Samsung SSL or optional SQ. LG- UVA.
-Foldable & detachable
-660w x 6 wide bars with protective coating over diodes.
-2.6 umol/j
-25% off Pre-Orders = $975 to your door.
This company is well known for its customer service + satisfaction, giving large discounts, helping our Veterans, ect... dont wanna sound Shilly. They creating the first Premium parts used & listed part #'s on the site, custom designed, enhanced white, Canna-Specific fixtures & was the first to state publicly they are designed to be used specifically for growing Cannabis when it was not publicly accepted .
Apache & Area51 opened the doors to enhanced white & Amare perfected it the best they could with the newest tech each yr., upgrading when possible.
New Website underway. No Bar-6 LUV on the sight yet. Basically this spectrum with a tiny bit less 450nm peak & the addition of 385nm. Providing 15% light outside the normal par region.20200323_003840.jpg


Another one out now is From the SE bulb HPS leader company : Hortrilux
This is less efficient then the one above but also a nice all in one.


Then there's these guys in which i support their work & admire their design. They have yet to incorporate UVA but do something the 2 listed above do not do. That is provide Near UV which in turn fills some of the gap white leds have between 400-450nm , has a vump of 470nm as well as extend the red tail into the Near IR zone.
This has allowed increases bag appeal as well as up to a 20% increase in thc & other cannabinoids shown through testing. This approach is called using a BroadBand spectrum which creates a light closest to the sun (in one chip) by means of only x2 diode k-temps.
They started as members here on RIU.

[/URL]

All x3 of these Led fixtures will eliminate the need to add a cmh, have 3-5 yr warranties, are HE, Reputable companies (Aussies are new but still very reputable)
The High-Lights do not include UVA but there is a thread here showing how Well they work in conjunction with CMH.
These Full-Spectrum leds are a slightly higher upfront cost then CMH, allot more then SE-HPS but Would reduce your electrical needs by either 50% or close, reduce or eliminate the need for AC.
If you already own a CMH or bulb fixture & are looking to get started cheap then i would just add an led Bar to each side n be done until harvesting enough to buy a good led.
Hope this helps. Good Luck!
 
Last edited:

Sif1

Well-Known Member
Or=
#5. New Led. The new leds available rn that will give you close to or better spectrum then the CMH (finally) while maintaining 2.1-2.6 umol/j. Those efficiency ratings are only measuring between 400-700nm. That provides the typical PPFD. When measuring the true spectrum you'll get a higher PBFD.
Representing the Normal par as well as what they call "The Beyond Par Region" (a term used to admit a mistake it sounds, lol!)
These New High-End (all in one true full spectrum with no need to supplement) Led fixtures are the best of both worlds I'd imagine. Still waiting on mine to arrive.
There's a few out there that know of:
1) Amare Bar-6 LUV. Canna-Spec + 385nm.
Canna-Spec spectrum includes x2 whites, 470, 630, 660 + 740nm to create a broad Horticultural spectrum.
On dual remote driver channels with dimmers allowing spectral blending & dimming between veg + flower modes.
-DIodes: 301H + Samsung SSL or optional SQ. LG- UVA.
-Foldable & detachable
-660w x 6 wide bars with protective coating over diodes.
-2.6 umol/j
-25% off Pre-Orders = $975 to your door.
This company is well known for its customer service + satisfaction, giving large discounts, helping our Veterans, ect... dont wanna sound Shilly. They creating the first Premium parts used & listed part #'s on the site, custom designed, enhanced white, Canna-Specific fixtures & was the first to state publicly they are designed to be used specifically for growing Cannabis when it was not publicly accepted .
Apache & Area51 opened the doors to enhanced white & Amare perfected it the best they could with the newest tech each yr., upgrading when possible.
New Website underway. No Bar-6 LUV on the sight yet. Basically this spectrum with a tiny bit less 450nm peak & the addition of 385nm. Providing 15% light outside the normal par region.View attachment 4515717


Another one out now is From the SE bulb HPS leader company : Hortrilux
This is less efficient then the one above but also a nice all in one.


Then there's these guys in which i support their work & admire their design. They have yet to incorporate UVA but do something the 2 listed above do not do. That is provide Near UV which in turn fills the lousy gap white leds have between 400-450nm as well as extend the red tail into the Near IR zone.
This has allowed increases bag appeal as well as up to a 20% increase in thc & other cannabinoids shown through testing. This approach is called using a BroadBand spectrum which creates a light closest to the sun (in one chip) by means of only x2 diode k-temps.
They started as members here on RIU.

[/URL]

All x3 of these Led fixtures will eliminate the need to add a cmh, have 3-5 yr warranties, are HE, Reputable companies (Aussies are new but still very reputable)

These Full-Spectrum leds are a slightly higher upfront cost then CMH, allot more then SE-HPS but Would reduce your electrical needs by either 50% or close, reduce or eliminate the need for AC.
If you already own a CMH or bulb fixture & are looking to get started cheap then i would just add an led Bar to each side n be done until harvesting enough to buy a good led.
Hope this helps. Good Luck!
I've used those leds for 9 months and they are not as good. Also, I'm in constant communication with Gavita as we are currently setting up a multi-million dollar cbd grow facility and it's their opinion also that LEDs aren't as good. However LEDs time will come but not just yet. I have trialled Valoya, Fluence, and several others so I know what I'm talking about. There are 2 main issues, 1 being if using LEDs alone you need to add heating, this negates the lower cost of running them. But, then if you think of buying a bar fixture to use inside a tent with the driver attached and inside the tent you will get a heat problem. They say the lights don't emitt heat, but the drives do, So if in a tent you really need your driver outside. 2 The cost to set up the size we are doing isn't viable. Its a 10yr to 12yr payback on ROI (return on investment) Oh, i forgot there's a UV issue also. You must have UV bars or just add a hps/cmh.

As for a small room hobby grower, they work ok and are worth playing around with. I have blended them, hps/led, cmh/led and a variety of other blends. The best blend for quantity, quality and low cost is without a doubt HPS/CMH blend.

Per square meter, it costs $100 using HPS/CMH and around $500 at least using LEDs. And what happens when your diodes die, burn out, driver burns out, it's a huge cost apposed to HPS/CMH where you can just replace the bulb or ballast.

If you are from Australia contact Wholesale Horticultural Group. They are real growers selling real products.


www.whg.net.au

Accent is average at best.
 

Sif1

Well-Known Member
Also expensive as fuck! I just couldn't justify spending $1700 on a light for a tent when you could spend 1/4 of that on 2 CMH and 99% of the growers would never see a difference. At a professional/Commerical level, these lights make sense.
Exactly my point. My job last yr was solely to test everything for our commercial setup. I've done the research and don't accept 90% of LED manufactures numbers.

And will add I'm an Investment Analyst mostly targeting financial markets.

Anyone notice Tilray price move? $2.50 to $10 in about 5 days in this market. perhaps its time to look more deeply into MM stocks.
 
Last edited:

farmingfisherman

Well-Known Member
Exactly my point. My job last yr was solely to test everything for our commercial setup. I've done the research and don't accept 90% of LED manufactures numbers.

And will add I'm an Investment Analyst mostly targeting financial markets.

Anyone notice Tilray price move? $2.50 to $10 in about 5 days in this market. perhaps its time to look more deeply into MM stocks.
What is the 10% you do except?
 

farmingfisherman

Well-Known Member
Exactly my point. My job last yr was solely to test everything for our commercial setup. I've done the research and don't accept 90% of LED manufactures numbers.

And will add I'm an Investment Analyst mostly targeting financial markets.

Anyone notice Tilray price move? $2.50 to $10 in about 5 days in this market. perhaps its time to look more deeply into MM stocks.
Tilray owned by a big pharma company? Looking at their website its what I imagine a big pharma operation looking like. I like knowing the weed I smoke has a story behind it rather than a warehouse with unhappy lab workers solely working there to collect a paycheck.
 

Sif1

Well-Known Member
Tilray owned by a big pharma company? Looking at their website its what I imagine a big pharma operation looking like. I like knowing the weed I smoke has a story behind it rather than a warehouse with unhappy lab workers solely working there to collect a paycheck.
Was just mentioning TLRY as it may have a flow-through effect on other MM stocks that have been sold off the past two yrs. TLRY have a product they send here. cost $1400 per month. We can supply a better product for $150 per month.
 

farmingfisherman

Well-Known Member
Was just mentioning TLRY as it may have a flow-through effect on other MM stocks that have been sold off the past two yrs. TLRY have a product they send here. cost $1400 per month. We can supply a better product for $150 per month.
gotcha
 

hybridway2

Amare Shill
I've used those leds for 9 months and they are not as good. Also, I'm in constant communication with Gavita as we are currently setting up a multi-million dollar cbd grow facility and it's their opinion also that LEDs aren't as good. However LEDs time will come but not just yet. I have trialled Valoya, Fluence, and several others so I know what I'm talking about. There are 2 main issues, 1 being if using LEDs alone you need to add heating, this negates the lower cost of running them. But, then if you think of buying a bar fixture to use inside a tent with the driver attached and inside the tent you will get a heat problem. They say the lights don't emitt heat, but the drives do, So if in a tent you really need your driver outside. 2 The cost to set up the size we are doing isn't viable. Its a 10yr to 12yr payback on ROI (return on investment) Oh, i forgot there's a UV issue also. You must have UV bars or just add a hps/cmh.

As for a small room hobby grower, they work ok and are worth playing around with. I have blended them, hps/led, cmh/led and a variety of other blends. The best blend for quantity, quality and low cost is without a doubt HPS/CMH blend.

Per square meter, it costs $100 using HPS/CMH and around $500 at least using LEDs. And what happens when your diodes die, burn out, driver burns out, it's a huge cost apposed to HPS/CMH where you can just replace the bulb or ballast.

If you are from Australia contact Wholesale Horticultural Group. They are real growers selling real products.


www.whg.net.au

Accent is average at best.
Dude, im sorry you did not find the benifits of leds over hps that i did. Its a shame because you were probably so close to unlocking the potential.
No offense, but 1/2 the stuff you said above is not true, rather you did not learn how to make the proper adjustments.
Also, i can assure you have not used the leds i mentioned above. If you tried regular white LEDs vs hps w/o modifying your techniques, then i can see why you say that. If you used properly enhanced white leds or new Broadband leds as well as got past the learning curve, then you would never think about hps again. All the bennifits of hps & mh together except you get twice as much light per watt of an even better Spectrum. Sure, there is defficencies in regular white leds for Horticultural purposes. They became famous for simple diy applications & happy results.
I know because i did it & stuck by until i did it right. Learning curve was allot harder then, then it is now because now you can get the correct info. To dial your grow using good leds. I had to suffer from trail n error along with allot of missinformation. Sort've like portions of your post.
I have cut my bill in half, have record breaking yields (for me), the bud is way denser & has more bag appeal. Probably higher thc too.
The bennifits to led are endless in comparison.
You just need the right leds & know how to use them & what to change in your environment & feed .
 

Sif1

Well-Known Member
Dude, im sorry you did not find the benifits of leds over hps that i did. Its a shame because you were probably so close to unlocking the potential.
No offense, but 1/2 the stuff you said above is not true, rather you did not learn how to make the proper adjustments.
Also, i can assure you have not used the leds i mentioned above. If you tried regular white LEDs vs hps w/o modifying your techniques, then i can see why you say that. If you used properly enhanced white leds or new Broadband leds as well as got past the learning curve, then you would never think about hps again. All the bennifits of hps & mh together except you get twice as much light per watt of an even better Spectrum. Sure, there is defficencies in regular white leds for Horticultural purposes. They became famous for simple diy applications & happy results.
I know because i did it & stuck by until i did it right. Learning curve was allot harder then, then it is now because now you can get the correct info. To dial your grow using good leds. I had to suffer from trail n error along with allot of missinformation. Sort've like portions of your post.
I have cut my bill in half, have record breaking yields (for me), the bud is way denser & has more bag appeal. Probably higher thc too.
The bennifits to led are endless in comparison.
You just need the right leds & know how to use them & what to change in your environment & feed .
I'm not selling anything. Are you?

How many Leds are you running? What size room? Medium being used? Show us your grow? Why is it most commercial grows still use HPSCMH?

Calculate the cost for me to run a 1000 sq/m room?

I have LEDs as good if not better than the ones you are running and prefer hps/cmh.
 

Sif1

Well-Known Member
Dude, im sorry you did not find the benifits of leds over hps that i did. Its a shame because you were probably so close to unlocking the potential.
No offense, but 1/2 the stuff you said above is not true, rather you did not learn how to make the proper adjustments.
Also, i can assure you have not used the leds i mentioned above. If you tried regular white LEDs vs hps w/o modifying your techniques, then i can see why you say that. If you used properly enhanced white leds or new Broadband leds as well as got past the learning curve, then you would never think about hps again. All the bennifits of hps & mh together except you get twice as much light per watt of an even better Spectrum. Sure, there is defficencies in regular white leds for Horticultural purposes. They became famous for simple diy applications & happy results.
I know because i did it & stuck by until i did it right. Learning curve was allot harder then, then it is now because now you can get the correct info. To dial your grow using good leds. I had to suffer from trail n error along with allot of missinformation. Sort've like portions of your post.
I have cut my bill in half, have record breaking yields (for me), the bud is way denser & has more bag appeal. Probably higher thc too.
The bennifits to led are endless in comparison.
You just need the right leds & know how to use them & what to change in your environment & feed .
$1500 USD to do 4x4. get real. ok if you are a small hobby grower or using shareholders funds and don't give a fuck. We are self-financed and do give a fuck. It's not viable. Period.

Its different beast.
 

Sif1

Well-Known Member
Thats a very small sample. I have 1000.s of pics. And have journaled everything. Gm per watt etc, time, ferts used, temps. mediums and all the rest. At the end of the day the hps/cmh was better, however hps,cmh added to leds was ok also, but it should be..
 

Sif1

Well-Known Member
Dimensions of the grow. Tents 6/ 3mx 1.5wx2.2h, with a 2.4mx 1.2m table. Best i did with Leds was about 3lb, Best with HPS was 5.3lb that's not bs either.. The best strain was Bruce Banner from ILGM.
Best grow was 1.31 gms per watt.

I have a heap of other Led samples on other computer. Have tried the one you like, but the numbers are the same as the ones in the pics. Oh, i also have tried king stectrum, california lightworks. too many to remember.
 

Sif1

Well-Known Member
Dude, im sorry you did not find the benifits of leds over hps that i did. Its a shame because you were probably so close to unlocking the potential.
No offense, but 1/2 the stuff you said above is not true, rather you did not learn how to make the proper adjustments.
Also, i can assure you have not used the leds i mentioned above. If you tried regular white LEDs vs hps w/o modifying your techniques, then i can see why you say that. If you used properly enhanced white leds or new Broadband leds as well as got past the learning curve, then you would never think about hps again. All the bennifits of hps & mh together except you get twice as much light per watt of an even better Spectrum. Sure, there is defficencies in regular white leds for Horticultural purposes. They became famous for simple diy applications & happy results.
I know because i did it & stuck by until i did it right. Learning curve was allot harder then, then it is now because now you can get the correct info. To dial your grow using good leds. I had to suffer from trail n error along with allot of missinformation. Sort've like portions of your post.
I have cut my bill in half, have record breaking yields (for me), the bud is way denser & has more bag appeal. Probably higher thc too.
The bennifits to led are endless in comparison.
You just need the right leds & know how to use them & what to change in your environment & feed .
At the end of the day. It it works for you, thats all that matters. Being a Hortilux product i would say they are pretty good, but the price kills it.
 
Top